Socialist Challenge No. 52, 29 June 1978
The scan: sc-n52-jun-29-1978.pdf (PDF, Marxists Internet Archive)
Uncorrected machine reading of the whole issue. This text was read by machine (Apple Vision OCR) from the scan and has not been corrected or cut into articles. Each page gives the headlines first, then the columns in order, so one article runs on into the next. Expect misread words. Use it to find things; quote from the scan.
Page 1 scan of this page
Socialist Challenge RACISTS ARE
FIRE
Algemon Road -
UNITE AND
FIGHT BACK
trade union. Make it a campaigning and fighting organisation.
Support all communines against racist attacks and police
people to organise their own self-defence.
Demand harassment at sirports and detention centres. Demand the repeal of the racist Immigration Acis.
PLAYING
WITH
Or offices in crntral Loodoo are
Age in camed. No arist (For details see P. 3)
Ishaqee Ali, an Fast End Bengali, dies after a physical ssault hy two "unknown" racists. No arvests so far. He isthe second Asian to be killed within a few
al David Foster upersos of Lewbham 21 Defence Committee, i shot at from # passing cat by a racist or racists "unknown'. A bullet enters his intestines and he is hospitalised. Numerous other incidents conse to light. Nourrests. (Demo organised for Sut 1 July at 2pm. Asaemble Loampit Hil, SEI3, corner of
- site of one of the shootings).
Build the ANL in every locality and
struggles black
Win support for the right of black
end stale
No.52, 29 June 1978, Price 1
YELLOW
CARD
SUH BACK PAGI
REVIEW:
'THE
SHERIFF'
PAGE 15 GAY PRIDE
IS
WORLD
WIDE PAGES 8& 9
Page 2 scan of this page
The Conservative Saga
OUR POLICIES 2
EDITORIAL
Socialist Challenon,
Massacring the truth
were carried out by the Smith Government's troops.
refugees (snother reason for not bothering to report it).
In the warlike noises issaing from the White House. the prospect of a new Vietnam in Africa. Cuban revolution.
from the Florida coast.
movements to call in outside workers" states to offer unconditional aid to such movements.
weaknesses or deformations.
Africa! Imperialist Hands Off Cuba! Guantanamo! by its brutish indifference to
*This was not for want of trying.
opening ceremony
French, But Lery is a Jewish same TV leam was demonstration by relatives of those who have disappeared.
some good comments from French players, tators are prone at the best of times
final was disgraceful.
in seeing their team win.
political rights.
home team were proved dramatically wrong. a victory for burbarism.
If you agree with these principles and want
lo be involved in activities by Socialist
Challenge supporters in your area, fill in
the form below and send it to us.
• 1 am interested in more information
bout activities in my area.
-I would like additional literature and
enclose 50p to cover costs.
(Delete If not applicable]
NAME
ADDRESS
Send to Socialist Challenge, 328/9 Upper
St. London N1,
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 1978 page 2
Street, London
MASSACRE time is here again. The killing of 12 British missionaries in Zimbubwe was the signal for another Kolner-style bout of hysteria. The purpose of this propazinda was made clear by the press's refusal to countenance the likelihoed that the killing»
The previous day there was an even larger death toll, just over the border in Mozambique. This time the culprits were definitely Rhodesian troops (which is why you probably missed it in the British press), Seventeen of the victims were black Zimbuhweun
This nauseating propaganda offensive reflects more than the innate racism of the Western media. It also signals their fear that Imperialism is losing its grip on Africa. This has been most marked
This has two alms. The first is to indicate that imperialises has had all it can take from the African liberation movements. The bloody cautionary tale of Vietnam has dissuaded America from any similar escursions in Africa — even at the cost of a major
But the Zaire crisis restored the upper hand to the Pentagon nuwas. Caner personally mus spent the tust to montos an horough ideological preparation for resistance against the "Soviet imperialле татеи сгене, ше илиов movements yand ме ma now ract
No evidence has appeared to sapport US В ДЕЦІ ПОЦІ М 0О 0800 10 5060063316 secondary question. The essential point is that imperialism will use any pretext to intervene against the revolutionary threut 90 miles
We have many differences with Cubun strategy in Africa. In particular we have frequently criticised their blind support for the Ethiopian regime. But we still defend the right of liberation
help and the responsibility of
The Cuban revolation has fundamentally transformed the lot of the Caban manes and stood as a beacon for revolutionary and anti-imperialist forces throughout the world. This is despite all its
That is why all socialists must demand: Imperialist Hands Off
Americans Out of
After the game is over
BRIAN CLOUGH put his finger on it, minutes after the end of the World Cap final. Mario Kempes must be a bit pissed off, he said, with old General Whatsisname hogging the limelight. What better political plutform could he hope for, for the Argentiniun
It was a brief moment of sanity in a mediu spectacular murked
what was really going on i Argentina. Those who Imagined that this publicity could be we in highlight the vicious record of the Videla dictatonship wete
Two West German commentalors made critical remurks about the regime during the
and found themselves confined to their
French journalist Bernurd-Henri Levy was arrested as soon as he arrived in Argentina. Police said to him: You say you are
"He was only allowed to stay four days and had to stay at a hotel chosen by the junta. A French
prevented from transmitting • report of •
Even more successful initistives, such as the Swedish team's support for a demonstration by relatives of the disappeared and
passed almost unnoticed amid the mindless hysteria to which foothall commen-
Many people feel that the Argentiniun team were unworthy winners. There are question marks over muny of the refereeing decisions throughout the tournament und their behaviour in the
The politicsi tragedy and the footballing injustice are obviously linked. The built-in advantage for the bome team is magnified in a right-wing dictatorship where the regime has a political Interest
The nationalism which permeates all football is taken to the nth degree under a regime like Argentina's. Nationalism is their justification for torture, assassination and the deprivation of all
The scenes after Argentina's victory — presented as just quaint South American good fun —were u victory for that nationalism. Those Argentiniun oppositionists who called for a victory for the
The World Cup was a defeat for the Argentinian working class;
HOME NEWS
SCENE 1:
Thaicher, George Wurdenerantz, and Robert Mosseistern. All three ure discused us witches
GEORGE:
THATCHER:
ROBERT:
GEORGE: And the place?
THATCHER:
ROBERT:
ALL: Enoch calls: — anon! -
Scene 2: Party headquarters in lan Smith Square. A large
adviser, Sherman Tank.
THATCHER:
victory
Of our once great party.
TANK:
And know TANK:
Callahodge will soon fall Michael of Brill Welcome good gentletok. Welcome all.
WHITE LAW: Good lady,
Callahodge grows
rage, froths at the mouth and farts uncontrollably)
THATCHER: Fie on it! Oh fiel
Will no one rid me of
WHITE LAW:
T TANK:
We still have our clubs
to use thom
Has a piercing nail, Known to you all as the Daily Mail.
THATCHER: We use the white ciab
An open field near Ascot. Enter Lady
Shall we three ever meel again, Has my struggle been in vain?
When the hurly-burly's done When Labour's lost and we have won!
Methinks that will be this autumn.
Why Downing Street, Sir. No 10, if'all goes well, But now let's move posthaste to hell There to meet our Lord Powell.
Fair is foul and foul is fair, Hover through fog and filthy air.
commitler room. Enter stage right: Lady Thatcher and her chief
O that chis roo, too aatul situation Would melt, thaw and resolve itself into a
How weary, stale, flat and boring is the rhetoric Heath, Heath, that blasted Heath, that damned Heath is to hiame for al this.
If the soldiers had been despatched to Saltley
We would not now be in this sorry state.
Tis not the tallen Heath that worries us But the Sqaire Callahodge.
He is crafty, wily, almost a fox Gracious lady, do not despair, We'll paint him a lurid red, "Te a colour hated in this land Your Sherman Tank has all in hand THATCHER: Here come our good lords from the battlefield. (Enter Earl White Law, Lord Joseph, Sir Geoffrey Who?, Duke
Welcome good gentlefolk.
What news from yonder house?
Get more confident.
He no longer says 'if we win", but when And sitting at his fect are Lords Foot and Benn (At the sound of the word Benn, Sherman Tank turas purple with
this turbulent government?
What weapons have we lell?
Weapons! Why very few ma'am Ourslings and arrows have gone, Our uniforms have been stolen
Our nakedness. (He weeps)
My Lord White Law comes close to treason, Our foot-soldiers from the backwoods are ready
And one club in particular
But Callahodge answered it with an even more Capitali-m is in crish. The leaders of the Labour Parly and the trades anions iter salutions that are in the loterests, not at the worker, bet of the capiralist
Socialist Challenpe helleses that the In vital tasks confessing
- To huild Brod-based class sirwu tendencies in oppostion in class collaborationism in the laboor movement, These shnult he nna-exclusive in character grouping sogether militants helding a wide range of political sions. • To begia lo fight for ine creation of a united and democracie persiailunary sociabst organiction which can, throwsh an application of united front tactics, hegin de be wei an an alienative by thousands of workers engaged in streagles
Such an organisation shuuld be haved un the understanding that:
The struasie for socialism seeks to unite the fight of the workers agalest Mack people, Kats. struggling for lheir liberation. This socialism can out be achleved by creating new organs of power and defiating with all
Select chit
Southall AIREY THE KNAVE:
TANK: They shall madame.
The tamily chib The banging club,
women THATCHER:
TANK:
(Laughter and applause)
AIREY:
Are lightine tor
THATCHER:
Let him say it aloud
TANK: Weshall,
Black faces swamping our pleasant land Our beleaguered Orange friends in the North,
And the threat of War The rivers of blood shall scream out:
No more wantonness in our cities No degenerate pansies corrupting our children No more drugs on prescription. Weshall end poverty By abolishing the dole That must be our manifesto, For Be sourcern soul
(Brinstone and thunder outside. Exit all.)
Enter three an Johnson, and Lord Worst Thome. They sing the finale:
ALL: Labour are Reds.
Labour are Reds, Labour are Nazis.
Look Under Your Bedi Or you i catch the decise.
Don't be deceived by Callahodge, Don't be deceived by Healey.
Javid Owen is a sop
And as for Rees, well really
The man to watch is Wedgie Benn, He hasn't lost a single spot, And if you vote Labour He'll just have you shot!
We'll fight for Capital Well fight lot Probit We'l fight for Freedom With Vorster and Pinoshit.
Our sociatiom will he safinisely more dea
Wielded by the old peasant Hidwell from
Tinse then to use the orange club It's never talled us in the past.
But others must be kept in reserve.
The club against licentiousness and loose And nen who wear make-up!
Gentlemen you have revived my spirits Tknow our people well, War once one of them myscit, Fought in the Spanish Wars But on the wrong side Now T'U take them all for a ride.
Madame 1 too did light Against the Nasi Tribes.
And methinks that what Callahodge
Has much in common with our enemy of yore The Knave has a point, Let it be spread all over the land Wehave bur tew weapons iell Let us use all of them Weshall conjure up such visions of despai That even Callahodge will pause to reflect.
The Red Barbarians clambering on the white cliffs of Dover
Enough, no more killings of babies in their mothers' wombs.
meratie thas what esist in
ties and will offer fall sapport to all those fighting for socialin democras
scale. This unity will in the long run be dochive in defeating be Imperialist regimes in the West and the brutal dictatorships thes sustaie in 1a In triuin it Implies demanding the immediate withdrusal of Bria Foin Irdand und biting the trih people determine their own future
The Communist Parties in Europe are In crisis. S
4 tates for the teries are tape it state Men ter
raties for the overthrone of the capitalist state. Now less socialist parties are more necesary than ever beforr. Candi are one Tarunrable than over the preceding three decades. Bai such po only he built be mejecting sectarianism and seeing internal drmocrac luxury but us a sibl newcolty. This means the right to egganise tar
Page 3 scan of this page
What they say about the Anti Nazi League conference
APPEAL!
HOME NEWS
Detailed
work"
NIGEL HARRIS, member of
the ANL's steering committer
and of the Socialist Workers
The central aim of the con-
of all those who are committed
to an acus campalza acainst
the NF in the short period
Dolore the General Electim
The Front is committed to
oliciine 316 candidates. and
the clection could be the make
or break political test for the
Front.
The 80,000 people whio at-
tended the 30 April Carnival
showed the potential for the
ampaiga, but if it remains o
he level of an occasional even
of this kind se will not alti-
mately defeat the Froat.
For that, we need continuing
dsciplined and detailed work
locality, in housing estate, street,
в отарісс, ді суспу 1ootoal
match and on every football
Such a campaign tequires a
body of committed actursis af
many thousands, cach in their
own circumstances dedicared
to mobilising many more at
election performance of the
Front.
The campaign conțerence
will bring together that body of
activists that already
around the ANI, as well as
representatives of the anti-
fascist committees engaged in
parallel campaiens,
focal and national trade union
bodies.
The task is to define clearly
our individual responsibilities
uh it's not a central
task of the conference, it will
also. take important
anti-racist and anti-fascist
campaigas in differen: locali-
ellect of dur a and activities.
Alter the General Election
propose to hold a full
nationa conference to detine
our longterm tasks and our
anta sructure Inc Success
of the campaign in the
five ELOI3 Provide 19 with the most powertul indica-
Hon or what those lasks and
structures should be.
"Support mass action'
COUN TALBUT, member of the International Marxist Grosp's Central Committee:
Why has the ANL been so saccessful? Because it has been able to take the fight against racism and fascism heyond simply the far left, to involve tens and teas of thousunds of people in anti-lascist activities.
Is that cneagl? No. clearly not. But it is an escellent start. For that reason the IMG B falls conmitted to building the A NI on a losg-term husis.
We consider that the conference should map out a series of maw campaigns and activities. li should call a mass demonPhoto strainen in the automa election perio and organise a conference limed ut its sapporters in the trade unions and youth.
It should also step up les work on racism, involving itself in campaigi activities on immigration, racist widacks, sus luws, and so on. In short. the conference hat do por on
supporting mass action lo defeat racism and Tascism.
To carry out this ambitions programme of evenis, Leuque should elect a fully representative national council with the suchority to decide
activities heiween
•Programme
of activity?
DAVE COOK, national orgacach miser of the Communist Part: |
1. Thope that the conference
£25.000 appeal to
damape ANI.
2. That the conference will
achieve a much higher level of
Involvement by the trade union
movement in the ANt
3. I hope the confereace will
lay the basis for a programme
of activity throughout the sum-
mer which can have a big effect
on lhe results in the mance Crist hundred pine constituencies
that the NF says it will contest
at the General Election, as well
as ruisiny the level of anti-
fascist consciousness among
working people.
4. Thar it will belp clurify the
sometimes confused relation-
ship at a local level between
antracit committees and the
ANE, recognising that beth
have important roles to play.
5. That it will help yet rid of
the
alleces some areas of anti-
fascist and anti-racist work. and
6. Out of the activity thal 1
hope the conference will make
posible, the basis can be laid
for a really large representative
conference of all sections of the
lalur, anti-fascist, and anti-
racist
autumn. That can belp make next the ANt more representative
and democrutic with
roots in all sections of British
society.
COLIN TALBOT conferences. This should he a broad und open body involving the fullest range of support for Ile League.
We are confident thut with SUCh a cumpsicniog urienta. font and democratic structure the ANI. cun register a big step Forward from this conference
the DELEGATES credentials for the confereace from: Anti Nazi League. PO Bos 151, London WC2H TJO.
THE ANTI Nazi League has been the fastest growing campaign that the left in Britain has seen since the days of Vietnam solidarity in the late '60s.
It was the massive success of the ANL Carnival in April which persuaded the League's steering commitfee that a conference was necessary.
The national conference is to be held at the
ERNIE ROBERTS, member Df the ANL's steering commitree and prospective Labour Parlamentary candidate:
League's founding statement uy for the and the signing by many MPs DE HORCULE SUE HELLE 1977 Labour Party conference has within the labour movement, from all political tendencies and from many thousands of young people. that still the
deeper bE leaflets.
thousands of pounds. the result of one thing
April.
"Extend the unity"
Since the formulation of the takeover
gathered wide suppor
organising the ANL committee,
the campaiga conference ANL ofens afiet Dre police fuund NF roles OK slogan on wall
•These are the offices of the Anti Nazi League alter they had heen deliberately set on fire. Tens of thousands
brochures and pamphlets have destroyed. Extensive dumage has been caused to the huilding itself. The cost of this act of arson will cua Into #This is not the only incident of violence. The Ant Nazi League organiser in High Wycombe, a busnian, received a parcel homb. Threatening phone-calls to the League's organisers are commanplace. Meetings have heen broken upt in one, a smoke bomb was thrown, al another three people were put in hospital after being attacked with wooden clubs. The level of racial assaults and barrassment continues to rise. In East London, three black people, one a len yeur old boy — have died as a result of murderous racialist attacks. • This rising incidence of Nazi and rucialist violener is
large numbers of people to stop the growth of Britain's new Nuzis — the National Front. #There was the 80,000 strong And Nazi Carnival in
BE Truse Unionists, sche sdedents, women's groups are organising against Nazi
STOPTHE
Porchester Hall, London on Saturday, 8 July. All ANL groups, anti-racist committees, and trade union orgamisations that have sponsored the League are urged to send delegates.
Socialist Challenge asked five leading activists what they would like the conference to achieve.
he made to strenetheo and extend this unity in the labou and trade union movenienis.
Ally altempl to make
hid by political party will destroy the splendid unity which has been
There la a need to extend the
of the League throughour the country.
10 activities led by the national steering
it is essential to United bave a working committee with representatives from all arcas defeated
EMERGENCY
Nazi NF. heen ANE down. • growing determination hy
Name
NAZI Address
ERNIE ROBERTS
build unsted anti Nazi, anti-racist organbation in all parts of the country
we shall crow strength. Divided we shall be
the •No longer can Nazi candidates put forward their racialist polson unopposed.
MAnti racists everywhere are organising to stop the
Bin the locul elections in May the Nazis suffered humiliating set-backs. •The Anti Navi League, together with commitlees up and down the country, hus played its par in building up this movement.
•Now the Nazis are becoming worrled. So they une turning to urson, violence and intimidation to silence the Anti Nazi League. They dure not put forward their Nas bellefs in public. Instead they resort to cowardly attacks by night or in the dark alley.
Min the coming General Election the Nazis are pulting up at least 350 candidates. Their racialist propaganda will be everywhere. They must be opposed. •By buring our offices the Nazis want to close the They atast not saceced. Our campaign aguinst the Nacis needs to go on, getting ligger and stronger. To de this we need money urgenily. •Please give non!
TO: Emergency Appeal, Anti-Nuzi Leugue P.O. Bux 151 London WC2
YOUR HELP IS NEEDED NOW Tenclose a donation for the Emergency Appeal Layahle lo "'Anti-Nazi League"")
NATIONAL FRONT!
'Fight racism'
the Instilule Race Relacions:
I tbink the Anti Nazi League has dobe a tremendous joh in mobilising progressive forces in chis society against the
Bur if the purpose of this conlerente 15 Eo tase Sock 1r Larder to go forward, there are make.
Insofar as the ANL does nor address itself directly and specifically to the question of racism, which is the reccuiting ground of fascism, the Lengue only succeeds in driving the fascists off the streets in to the
mer cien aliene tred
crevices and ratholes of the
where they then resort to
vicious and violent attacks on
the black community, terror ising women and children.
Hence the ANL must give priority to liaising with and InUI
are Fighting local insues of racism and therefore fascism.
To fight fascisan and racism only secondarily (and this is my second point) - is to allos lascism to re emerge in
mirise Thatcherite anti racist Phone Anti Nazi League SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 1978 page 3
Page 4 scan of this page
The leadership wants to drop direct action
HOME NEWS
is annual conference this weekend.
sadents have taken action
political issues fighting school closures, to tackling sexism.
TONY side NUSS organiser: Much of he political action taken by students in the past six months has by-passed the NUSS.
For example. School Kids Against the Nazis has been tremendously successfat in getting students involved in antiNF activity. But the leadership of NUSS has made no real effort to build on this:
In fact at the conference they are proposing we drop
direct action against the NF. This means dropping our no platform position.
My area is opposing this. We want to see a clear anti-racist
want to see full and active support for SKAN.
BARBARA, active in the antiCALLE CICHELE Wandsworth schools in South LonGua- CITE NUSS hasn't taken a lead in any of WHY NOT have a Vacances Rouges or a Red Holiday? It will he fun, sun and politics in the Bosmue Coontre in worth ern Spain this summer.
Throughout July and Aug ust, the Fresch Revolutionary
Spanish Revolutionary Communist Youth are organising a
of 10-day holldays.
Young members, sympathisers ur those interested in the politics of the Fourth International are welcome.
150 moung revolutionaries at a time, from ail over Europe, will he exchanging expenences
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 1978 page 4
School students conference
against the NF'
THE NATIONAL Union of School Students holds
It comes at a time when thousands of school
on a wide range - from the Anti Nazi League, to
Where does the NUSS stand, and what will it be doing in the next year to build a mass movement in the schools? Socialist Challenge asked three candidates for the union's executive for their comments.
COLLINS, Humber- | the big problems we're facing - raciani, sexism, unemploy And students lois SkAN while thousands school the NESS has set up its own anti-fascist campaige. This has no impact among young peoSchool students want action on these issues.
Et up with organisations ke SRAN Me arional bertion with organisations like Campaign, and the We can't avoid politics We can he political without tying. our union to any particular party Al Leis coce 1 want lo see a mure towards socHist poles and a national executive which will union. If it co-ordinated mass NUSS could have
THE NAZIS
STEEL PULSE
BUZZCOCKSI
CHINA STREET
SATURDAY JULY 15 RALLY AT 12N00N STRANGEWEYS, BURY NEW RD MANCHESTER MARCH TOMHMAMLNMA ALEXANDRA PARK SPONSORED BY NORTH WEST REGION TUC
Vacances Rouge
debating, sun-bathing, enjoy ing music, sport and
Sixty places at the Vacances Rouges have been reserved for supporters lenge who are under the age of
cost? E45 excluding transport. But much lower If the places filled. There are reductions for school students.
For further details write to "Vacances Rouges', c/o Socialist Challenge. PO Box London NI.
response.
Bur this will mean the end of cos camous via le bead
of SENORIS
Students won't join a union because heads. They join if they think JEs camble or modelsire defence of their rights (denied 10 99 per cent of schoolsi against the racism and sexism which many heads are happy
NESS In Manchester: We're trying to organise a woek action on with the ANL Northern Carnival on 15 July:
If we can get kids involved in
The NUSS will
Cardiff Carnival unions, THE AFTERMATH of the League probably been similar all over the country. Great, now let's go and organise our own carnival!
DEREK ports on the plans of the big Cardiff Against Racialism for a South Wales Carnival.
The Carnival in Sourb Wales will he Fascism. Its main aim will be to get the local black community involved. Ir any ment came out Carnival in East London it was from the lack of black support. We hope this won't be the case in Cardill.
There hax response from the Asian and Local black Cardiff already. being steadily ghettoised in the slums of Kiverside.
The National Front in South Wales is weak, dentoralised b its failure in a recent Cardifi by-lection. But the County Council has tried block the progress Carnival. It recently refused to allow the ANt or the Carditi Committee Against to book meetings.
The Tory-led Committee of the City Council also made disruption when it attenipted to cancel the hall booking, When faced with opposition from the lors, the Racial Equality, as well us the organising Council backed down.
The Carnival celebration tures. A procession will march through: Cardiff on 15 Jule, led cultural by asteel band and a jazz band will comtumly, poblical and trade ution contingents. In the afternoon there will be Sikh dancing. karate and gymnastic displays, a male voice choir. theatre groups, music, stalls food, and exhibitions tracing this can be the rise of racism
In the evening there will be a concert with reggae, punk, rock and Junk rock bands CARNIVAL AGAINS
adit, Saluriay 15 July. Amenb 50, 11 Kam. At Lascour Square. Bute St Bine. Miren sia Guesn St to sochia
to the Carnival and
TALUES
many Members of Union
election for international 30b Catalisbaison
charperson of similar groups.
anne to connelle
Showi the
ANTI-RACIST IN BRIEF
Gabialist Challenge.
London Anti Nazi Carnival has
bands. youth shaatre.
DAVIES re- Charles B
Tel. Cardirl 41938
Committee Newham ANL
began and time Plashet of the ANI The march,
CARF.
been some Several hundred
community in Broadside
Theatre in Asians are Some 300
one incident, .Tory
of the
Racialismi schools for public a plate glass window.
However it dockers Amenities assailants — who
ted. last required Line
the police
Commission for
the ANI is now commitiee, the
London Trades will be
THE
cils, which b
15 July, announces:
after Welsh folk
selling cthnic
CARF
racism.'
Racism
lord
the mectings, we can pet then
leafler there An important part of what we'll be doing is taking up the problems students have experienced wearing anti Nazi
In the Mosa Side by-election, the VF candidate is a teacher
the Nationa cachers
strend mened the op
joining forces with SKAN to COLICE MORE ERECTO eir one position , in the NUSS
Uaf secretary This with the Chile Solidarity Campaign and
I have attended neetings of the Mauchester Anti-Recruitment Campaign and we deci ded to leaflet against the Army
Manchester Flower Musa No.no or comme!
SLEDGE.
Colchester
Strike Aller THE FIVE hundred who
the anti-fascist march from Ilford on Saturday were ded to sel Joined by another five handred
they reaclied anti racist •New ham activity reports TONY BROWNE
organised by Newham ANI and Redbridge inits work
was made up almost entirels of local poople and led by a local band. the Tickets. Mobile Warkers the the perk, and Two licened to the regene discu
racist rouths, DIEEVTAHULNOCEI AILE
- beckled tbe march. seven of the youths set upon two dockers as slogans. they were making their way to the star of the march. One of
ANL pramplly found himself calling through treatment.
Swat the THO THATS not their were arres dockers stitebes after beiag bit with a truncheon by
None of this detraces from the success of the march, and
likely to increase its work in the area
Taunched Council Conference
GREATER London caclalists", association Orades CoUr- LIAMY.
10 hold Bast minute
"This will be the Saturday
the AND conference and will chas be able to take into account both its decisions and the lessons learned from
conterence charing the way forward for DELISS trade unsonists in combatting
Delegates from trade union organisations, 50p cach, Cre denimbs from: P Masters. 433 sponsor of St Albans Rd. Seven Kings.
Ant
Noz gue 'WE'LL BE BACK' was the chant that went up at a picket of new National Front headquarters Hundrede of anti-lascists from Nollingham Trades Council and
Loughborough AN and anti-racist committee.
Loughborough — the latest incident was by several racists who enfered the premises of an Asian ANL member, ripped down posters and terrorised an employee
But the fascists have not had it all their own way. They find i
dillicult to hold meetings in pubs because of pressure oi broweries locally
countered by local milllants
Colchester ANL ANE OVER TWO hundred people carne to a public meeting in UMEENITSSHURIOR SAILMET to hear Peter Hain, the ANL's
ENTE TOTIN MIKE
The meeting, against racism ter Trades was called b Council One local activiss described it as the biggest left mecting In The town since the General
•hearint the exner enoss of Ipswich and Harwich anti-racists, the meeting deci- ties, Franch orthe ANi, pledged to Colchester
and anti lascist
11 will aim to involve a wide cross-section of the community
Huddersfield ANL RACISTS have been besy Dersbury, near Federated.
Asian shops were Tiles daubed with NF slogans on Friday night, and the windows of Staincliffe school, where a third of the students are Asian, were virtually obliterated with
Bailey advice centre, whic i also the HQ of Dewshury
received The League park. counter these activities
supporters allended a meeting in Had dersfield on Saturday to elect delegates for the A NI. national conference or July.
Plymouth ANL
The Plymouth branch of the Anti Nazi League las been
after weeks threats, bans. NF thogeery and hampering by moderate anti-
writes ED VUL.
Local ANE organisers facod
CCNRECIAEEST inaugural meetings planned in Aptil and May after the Devon County education authorities and the Quaker Swanhmore Foundation backed down 1o thecals of fascist violence, and refused the league use of their
The AN was banned from all educational buildings.
LILI though Devon's chief educatson officer, Mr Joss Owen, is a
moderate Devon and Corraall Association for Racial Equality
Nottingham
joined by militants from
on the increase in
and public sales of their paper have been
Days after the ban, a local
organiser was attacked by NE members in a husy shopping centre watched shoppers and police who did nos intervene
But Pamouth sation En bour Parly called the fuscists buff and offered their hall to the ANL, despite subsequen threats to their tamubes from Beibers the Front
The mccting went ahead peacefely in the packed anu guarded hall, The new branch collecied affiliations Tron trade intom the Liberal Labour and Communal Par
IMG, SWP and anar LEISSE
The NE clan 80 meccibers in Plymourt, some or waont are
the Police Royal Marines, they slate. Earlier this seas, local NF organise Garden Cummins was expelled from the Front Information to a newspaper abou. the undercover activities of fascists leaking secreis from inside the navy and compiling
OIL Socia Socurity claimants,
Portsmouth ANL OVER 250 people took part in the Portsmouth ANL march on Saturday despite attempts by the local Tory council to ban it from mecting in a city
Permission was refused for Victoria Park to be used for a rally with speakers and a rock group at the beginning of the march. The Icader of the council said the ANL made up of extremiss and the tient arainst fascism war 'super fluaus
Marchers did meet in th park and a meeting was held
elore the demenstration se ell, led by a Rock Agains Racism proup. About 5.000 Jeaflets were distributed. Tere demo ported by Portsmouth Trade: was, ULICSIOLE
Council and conturgents came from Southampton and Br shion.
'THE SOCIALIST CHALLENGE
TO
IMMIGRATION CONTROLS
The how why. what, and
THETBION controis - all in a pamphlet Just out for only 10p. Place a
The Other Bookshop, 328 Upper Street, London N1. CUT-D BoTT
Page 5 scan of this page
Terrorism from the
HOME NEWS
Challenge'.
Mills, Ronan Bennett (arrested 24 May). Dalydd (arrested 2 June), and Stewart Carr (arrested 15 June) are being held in Brixton Prison They are charged with conspiracy to cause explosions with persons known und unknown"
The Anti-Terrorist Squad also hopes to pin charges of armed robbery on two of the accused. The general line of police investigations was pur in court by Detective SuperinAnti-Terrorist Squad: "We are looking for Northern Carnival will be held in Moss Side just Iwo days after polling day in the by-election that has been called for 13 July. That's Socialist Unity along with the Manchester Socialist Workers Party will be concentrating their energies on running a campaign to build the Carnival.
BOB PENNINGTON reports.
Plans are already underwas to organise meetings outside schools at lunch-time, and local bew wave and releac rock
IF SCHOOL students could vote, Socialist Unity would have first councillor in GlasRow's Crosshill/Prospecthill ward.
This was the reaction of Socialist Unity workers after a week of hectie campaigning in the before chas gow's council by-clection on 25 June.
After Socialist Unity porlers had wiven out School Kids Against the Nazis leaflers in Iie schools in Clasgow's southside, the Socialist Unity cloction office becume a centre Jor school students.
NAZIS
The leafletting followed Nazi Glaspoe SCAnnIS. National Froor supporters been King's Park school and racist
Bellahausten
Raids against left continue
A NEWS story called 'Armed Police Raid Swansea Militants' appeared in the 15 June issue of 'Socialist
The grouping "Persons Unknown' argue that more les behind the raid than we reported. They explain.
Four peogle inchiding Iris | idealistic persons who would
take positive steps to overT.add threre society RAIDS Since the arrests there have been more than ten raids in LOBUOn - ns wel as those in Swansea, Sheffield, Huddersfield and possibly elsewtiere.
Anarchists have been the main targer, but other sections of the left have also been affected There has been no evidence bombings in Britain for more 3 wo sais race arrests and
Socialist Unity
campaigning in
Manchester...
THE Anti Nazi League's | bands will be asked to play at
in the area will ger a reception from local anti-fascists not only in the streets in Moss Side tut why aiso the campaien against los racist ideas will hit hire when he gues back to school after polling day.
LEAFLETS Every single day from the Anti Nazi League, Socialist Unty and the SWP will be icafletting puts, shop ping preciocts and lactories. calling for mass support for the Carrivat and urging the rout of the racist scum.
This will be in contrast with the Labour campaien which will no
...and Glasgow
its sup-
CHRIS BAMBERY demy. Bur last Wednesday saw a successful mecting to launch SKAN in Glasgow's southside.
School scudents were also in evidence a: another Socialist Unicy clection activie Aca- showing of the United Troops
'anti-terrorists'
thing and one
Mills, Bennett, Ladd and Carr
have been fisted up by the State
in order to mount a general offensive against the anarchist
and socialist left.
This comes al a time when
The Anli Terrorist Squad is
desperately urving to justity its
existence, following is recent
Yard on. and a week of awkward
questions in the House about
the commition and rele of the political police.
ISOLATED
The four arrested have been political
midated.
have the case of Iris Mills: noises. but will maintain a
discheet silence about the rucst
policies of the Labour Government and its support for mimigration controls.
Nor will the torch of political prisonens in Ireland be allowed
unity a the polls, A demonstrabion has been planned In sup port of Irish political prisoners who are 'on the blanket', This will probably be held outside militants one of Labour's election meet-
ABORTION
The Society for the Protec lion or the Unborn Chiid has raised its ugly head. Leaflets and posters lave appeared in Moss Side against plous One prontinent Labour Party Dut Movemens slet im *Honse Soldier Home Bridper 's Tolyelen.
As well as school Bide the bulk of the 65 strong audience were housewives, therebs proving the myth that solidarity work must be based DE hard drinking males
Socialist Unity's by-election candidate. Chris addressed the audience hetore the film started. Arguing for British Jand, Hambery Socialise Unity was the only participane in that took up the question of Ireland.
SPUC
A small group ot supporters of the anti-abortion outfit ilse Society for the Protection of die Unborn Child' disrupt abe meeting Bur they - AL found no views and for their accusation
Tong and ne polie oly held in thement prison si be
thing only:
in solitary delied association
prisoners.
Wing, degrading. is placed allowed.
Wing to every ward.
and after cach visit.
Our Iris are clear: that their lawyers and
socialist
Lunit
member has mobilise the
ORGANISE
working class abortion.
School, "chold murderer:
Irish
Bambery, POLICE withdrawal from Ire-
pointed cur One nos-European AUSSILCI the election own county".
Ibe police
new. Women tried contral their hadies
SUDDOLI JOT EDCIT
*She is the first woman to be • proDet
the Price sisters in 1975. She is
confinement and that
prisonces. In addition she has
to exercise in full view of male
*Not oely is this mind-bend-
insulting and
*When she is visited, a table
berween ber and het
visitor, No physical contact is This
Two screws hover ment on
"She is strip-searched before
demands concerning the be
given bail: failing this, that she
Holloway and granted association with other group
THE
threatened to Catholic vote against the Labour Party if the candidate dares to openly supporta woman's right to choose. that they
one
Militants don't intend that
renege on the decisions of its tion
women to the Big Flame. birchery of hack strom abor tion because it is thought to be
There won't be candidares
its presence will be very much
will use the election to help organise Challenge'. the lightback and prepare the way for standing candidates in discussed the any autumen general election. that because Bambery supporled a woman's right to choose
abortion that he was a
SPUCites were also active
Saturday afternoon when the National Aborion Cam-
mige, supporied by Socialis Unity. petitioned the local ou
exhibition showing method
NAC told by SPDCite to get back to your
same to the assistance of SPUC when they ordered un 'offending" section of the display to be hidden NAC was forced to comply.
This kind of censorship is not
fighting Tacing such harassment should jour with other NAC groups and labour movemen bodies to fight back
has
In the meantime we demand
Roman, Dafvdd and Stewart be allowed to visit Iris for social interaction as well as
purposes of defence, and that
Ronan Benner be allowed to wall her on the common law husband/wife basis.
PRIORITY
must be OLLE first priority because of the effects of prolonged solitary contine
prisoner. incaberence, disorientation, lack of identity. The effect of such treatment on a person in the Red dock, would be disastrous for the 'trial" and an attack on her polities: anarchist → crelin.
Mere generaily the support
demands: All those | Hall, Red Lion Square
ISA vote for
left unity
CONFERENCE organised by the Internatonal Socialist Alliance (former members of the Socialist Workers Party) attracted some 7U delegates on 17-18 June. Its importance lies in the fact
voted almost unanimously (with only
vote against) 10 campaign for a unified revolutionary organisa-
with the International Marxist Group and
Delegates also endorsed the decisions of the Steering Committee to participate on the Editorial Board of Socialist
On Sarurday the conference
political and cconomic situation in Brimain. It divided into workshops cr racism, feminist politics, and
where the discussion was both freer and extremely productive. A resolu ISA tion presented by Stephen
overwbelmingly adopted.
outlines policies — in addition to Our
25 the basis for a campaign for
boen
IMG
STEPHEN MARKS tion. Il commits the steering committee lo organise a furtber
the general election to draw up a balance sheel of the campaige and either found a united organisa-
1 arrested must be freed! Get rid
gale activities Suppression terroram
-Suppression Terrorism Lans:
IRISH
We recognise that the raids
-LE experience are perr of everyday
The British left on the whole
donc Little show solidarity and launch a general offensive against such repressive legislation as the Prevention of Terrorism Act
Now we are being harassed
way Irish people We appeal to all groups concerned with prisoners rights and with opposing such laws to help in this campaign so as to launch a general offensive against State
SOLIDARITY
*Public 1 міль: July
Free Tris Ronan Bennett, Dafydd Ladd and
Stewart Carr', Conway Hall
Lion Square Арт.
*Demonstrute: 15 July -Edeware Tube, 2pm.
*Benefit: 15 July, Conway for moving towards it"
Socialist Volce will continue to appear as popular broadly-based journal oF socialise news and analysis. although its exact form will be part of a further discussion.
Observers with speaking
Socialist Workers Party (Colin Smarksy International Markis Groun and bedie Weppler) Group (Tang Brian and Big Flamne (Peler Anderson, Jobn Hillier).
Colin Sparks appealed to the RICHARD KUPER
conference have dialogue with the SWP, and not to ignore the largest far-lett group in the country. He pointed to che successes of th ANt as a sign of the fact that
the SWPS political instincts had not deseried in
In response, Steve Marks pointed out that the ISA was very interested in a dialngue He examined how numeron approaches from Socialist Unity had been ignored, as had
appeals in Socialist Challenge.
A dialogue. Marks stressed could exclusive onc-sided. It should include the
and Big Flame, and equally important, independeat revolutionaries who agrec with the need for unity.
The test of new organisation will come in the months thar follow these decisions, All delegates stressed the necessity of joint work on every front to test out the ground before an organisation was launched,
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 1978 page 5
Page 6 scan of this page
Letting the bureaucrats
OPEN FORUM
conference in 1974. Sponsored the unions.
of the Labour Government in 1974, the first conference of the Rank and File Organising Committee in Birmingham attracted delegates from trade union bodies, including a significant representation from the industrial working class.
DISARRAY
We were entering a situation in which thousands of votes would be cast far revolutionary policies and candidates in the trade unions, accompanied by a hig increase in the size of the whole revolutionary left. contrast, the Communist Party was to industrial
in disarray and its membership declining rapid rate.
The stage was thus set for Rank and File to start to dislodee the Communist Party from ils positions of power and influence in the trade movement. This would baVE signalled the end of the CP* traditional position as the only
alternative to.
Labour Party,
But instead we have seen a growing decline of the Rank and File movement.
The SWP leadership and its
FICMONS have
devoted plenty ot energy to
building it. But the election of
commitlee.
off the hook
THE RANK AND FILE organisation held its first
by the Socialist Workers Party, it promised to be one of the most serious oppositions to the policies of the Labour Government. Today its influence is at an all time low.
RAY BURNS argues that the comrades of the SWP should rediscuss their whole notion of rank and filism, and join the fight for broad based fighting left wings in ONE MONTH after the return the Labour Government and
doweturn in Industrial misconceptions of the SWP.
SLAI proved to ne a disastrous combination for the new born The decline of the Rank and File movement should not be cause for pleasure on the far left. An important opportunity has been lost to draw hundreds of working class closer to revolutionary politics.
Nevertheless the facts must be squarely faced In the white collar unions, where Rank and File had won leading positions it lant ion among the ene basis bership. the decline is nost at a marked.
SPONSORED
union Rank and File has never really In the industrial unions got off the ground alternative to the Broad Left.
This unfortunately applies all projects sponsored by the the revolutionary left in this arca good militants have left the Rank and File affiliated organisations in disgust, pro testing against the organisacertainly bodier by the Socialist Workers domination
fightback
Fis NHS 30th anniversary
celebrate with resistance TORCHLIGHT VIGILS cude triedened nopras
Coneerce dy lt
FIGHTRACK, dealing with the Health Service, is one example of
militants organising to counter the Goverment's anti-working
class policies. Born out of the Hounslow Hospital occupution,
Fichtback Is broud-based and democratic, open to all those
prepured to organise together to blunt the axe on health.
The 30th anniversary of the NHS will be the nccasion of united
resistance. On Suturday, 1 July, a confererice to Defend Tendon's
Hospitals will he held at Porchester Hall, Queensway, London
W2, from Ipm to 5pm. It is called by the EGA shop sewards
On Tuesday, 4 Jely, diere will be evening torchlight vigils
outside London's threatened hospitals, commencing at 9pm.
Copies of Fightback, c/o Hounslow Hospital Occupation, Staines
Rowd, Harrow, Mdds. Tel 01-570 4448. Next week in Socialist
Challenge: the grim story of the Nulional 1t-bealth Service.
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 197d page 6
But the issue of control and democracy in these bodies die not come out of the blue.
The organisations had developed in the struggles against the Tory Government. When a Later Government launched savage attacks on working class hiving standards in the 1975, rank and filism' could not deal with the new situation.
Rank and Alism bases itself quite correctly on the ciass collaborationist role political trade union bureaucracy: upon the need for building a movement independent of the CHULECT
PROMOTING
But, by definition, rank and filism understands this ques tion of independence primarily milstants in organisational terms movement of the rank and file Hence its primary stress is on promoting unofficial channels through which mihtants can communicate, supposedly outside the control of their leaders.
Ir does this at the expense of
seeking to break the rank and
file from the
through a fight to force che
trade union leaders into united
ACTICAL The Rank and File policy
misunderstands
which the bureaucracy main
rains its hold.
based on more than burea-
cratic manoeuvres and suppres-
sion of union democracy, vital
bough these are in protecting
its privileges.
REFORMIST these
What has been decisive ar
holding back the working class
in the face of the crisis and the
attacks of
Government has
bureaucracy's
pennes
This question
brought to
dramatic
successes of James Callaghan.
For a broad laver of militants
has been convinced — al least
until the next clection
the only alternative to Labour
/ austerily is a Tory onslaught against the working class. credible which explains the triumph Callachan. Of course beca made possible by the role ol Scarlan, Jones, Basnett, ete.
But the mechanisas made the latter's class-collaborationism acceptable was tic
and File
ERDOUTSH sections of Britain's organised
warking class. merely restrict themselves to demanding more wages and militant MULL achieve Inc central demand of the recent strike by the and pickets! not
but also
voted to support Such would have won
NO APOLOGY
DUTCLUCIA
belpre. And
word transitional here
the way
demands
Its control is
mic against the state. Is this
massive
negative.
occupation
the Labour
been the reformist any other alternative Thus has been the fore in
by the employers
tha: nood 10 understood
Socialist Challenge
Trade Union
Conference
Saturday, 1 July, 10.30am
Digbeth Civic Hall, Birmingham
It is the lack of any other
political alternative it has
which
the militant
Alternative solutions abich
metbods same are totally today be insufficient. Thus the SWP'S anions,
during the
Brigades Union was for lying
only grossly other and broader overestimated the combativity of other sections of workers,
gravely underestimated the necessity of orienting is that this would be seen a to the 17 dissident members of the TUC General Council whe
an orientation socialists a hearing amongst the broader sections of rank-and-file work- organisations.
Furthermore, the question of what demands we raise is posed with greater urgency than ever
make apologies for introducing the
line.
The function of transitional
ID effect FRONTIST difficult passage trom econo-
political struggles less relevant today than before? questIons 0 be
One need only look at the planned and carried out today CouncincIs being to answer that question in the The SWP
Why was there no factory
at Speke waterent, Liverpool? Becausethe bureaucrats betrayed? Or was there something more; the lack of weakening
workers control demands are more necessary image" a than ever before. The powers of surveillance and veto over all
decisions without accepting any responsibility for Tuning a capitalist enterprise
stressed and
10.30-11.00 11.00-11.10 11.101,30-
3,00Georges
tickets.
Square, Contact
Friday
RANK AND FILE
Many of these powers could; unions. it is no coincidence that
stilised by trade but generalising workers control would mean extending veto powers till they should covered ibe entire life of the conference. enterprise and began to pose
questions. building
The latter would involve the question of economic planning and nationalisations. The poin TATES flowing out of a struggle rather than as the slogan at the end of an article in a left paper.
The problem is that those Who have tried to raise such questions in Rank and File
have disagreed with their direction in other ways. have soon found themselves excluded from the leading hodies and democratic discussion suppressed.
The SWP defends practices of this sort in the name of bullding the parly. But a party cannot be built by imposing its
mistakes But
In building the left in the
there aTE debated. party can only be bull insolar as if is able to show in practice that it has unswers — and good
united has partially acknowledged this. In a recent
said that the -frontist image of the Rank and File organisations noods oal
But to build a party, it is nor sufficient to "weaken a frontsi
- the frontist reality must be buried and genuinely
independent
organisation encouraged
This weekend's trade union
conference called by Socialist
Chullenge will he discussing the
task of rebelling the left in the
AGENDA Registration
1.30 3.00 Lunch (including
anions. 4.30 Fighting racism.
4.30- 4.45 Voting
4.45-5.00 Summary.
How to get there
HUDDERSFIELD: 7.30am SL
Square (opposite
Station): Phone 43099 for
CARDIEF: 8.20am from front
Students Union Park
Place. Phone 394755 for further
MANCHESTER: SI
Cost Socialist Challenge
centre 061-236 2332
SWANSEA: Contact Glyn
Jones, Swatisea 460473
GLASGOW: Star Social Club.
4 Carlan Place at 13pm on
night. E5 return.
Phone 041-221 3481.
BRISTOL: Christadel
a paper which has campaigned so forcefully far a new unifica revolutionary organisation
calling such
We believe that the asks of
resplutionary party and of building a clas struggle opposition CHIC inti-
related We don't believe thai Rank and File can of itself be transformed into a new left wing in the unions. POSTURING
We think that such a lett wing will be traili through forces at present in the Bread Left, in Rank and File. and outside both. It must be a united left democraFically organised and fighting for class struggle policies.
Socialist Challenge isn't abour to launch such an organisation. To attempt to de so would be to repeat the worst
SWP'S posuring that we ane the left?.
we are going to discussing has to fight for such a tiew left wing, Wesay to Rank and File members:
• Recognise that Rank and File is not the rank and file or the left in the unions Huild a
left wing fight to involve the Broad Left,
• Make Rank and File democratic, with the righ: of representation of all mutoritie
bodies of the organisation
forward adequate
policies to fight the bhidi
leadership on alt the key issues of the das
Organise broad-based
support commies with
workers in struggle; unite with
all forces on this, Demand the
official movement and leaders
support tini.
Opening remarks by Tariq Ali Rebuilding the left in the unions.
meetings of supporters from different sectors/
Contact
556354
BATH: 820an Talke Plat
Conrac: Mike
356554
LIVERPOOL: Pierhead
1.30anl. Contact SC sellers or
100 Whitechapel
Livapool 1.
LONDON: Coaches leav
London Com 12.4
retero from SCTU Confer-
ence, PO Box 50, London NI.
Cheques pasable to Socialist
Eat aton rund 6.4Sam University
LEEDS:
Steps, Woodhouse Lane
Phone 750635
BRADFORD: 7.00am Founh
Idea Bookshop. 14 Southgate
Phone 305927.
Page 7 scan of this page
SMEN = WOH
SHAMIN
e 1 pam IST1 aM. USU M
SauL.
эр во родо зм сутом омі
DUE INXISUEA1 DEN SU3UO M
mand pr
as punos sumas 1 0310m pe
-paa e dn aye 1, u00 J,
dot s pusmap pue paa
•pausa au
Tfg popuai asusaguo
sajef
341 (MOI.
Photo: G.M. COOKSDN [Boclallat Challeng»
pow puzz siy ur wou
su jo sautem
ANIT
Aap 0n PIp 000527
poo Sseu e 10g e3 gol haac
suspi
Sna soper sapond on top nou ImTE SAES 100
шаш шe4 g • SIN NICH порІння
S,IBUL, ONAS CONS AUL HaIL
SsI00 Tsest Sne tuams8mrnan say
15E1
drusip Aep sang sape Summoskos) sew aud
Azuens st wolan agt yanom
spinales
papoddns passagie
1e 11 pus 1,upр an Supdes 8330 504 -
a41: swa(gad
spanba au-pa-upape
LEENE SBOCHAR auo 03
Ssy pue yue
1013201 00 H
Ing
4305 anadad e
ISIXE SUCHAP SE S00j SE 104
TEST i sog saocido (pousddey ym Кред
-dns
LEISLAUR NOUR AIM
uotun
1
Ag reap are: 3101r
renbo ¿диор
301 SHer SOS TE
sa poM
TEN
RuI alos
ONINNIM
S.T0OIE
ul Bugsom n t08 " op mD Ino sul I Adou pagan = porodoad *aapaC
Хроотя papaau
Korea/y pappu
SEELOP
ble Lotun
de oa adol
an д пос у і шаць ура
On 2e 01 ino aueys
a lem 1 poe ascon pea
Jo
Is, nostapuns.
spel Lt SARIS
0n seppi 103 Agond E 2160
7/1-15
Quo os pue , maiorina
SY3ONNg
ino ursa dau
o sérer (
Suryaeq Jo A MALLOO P/DIOM
aup ut astacu paas Aunog
3G000000 BAN300 SE SIL
steunaspen MOY-SE 3004
Do gNos lo ruti aoi
:330 M
por monso saro
Spaant gEMOpEN T-MIESEL SUE sungãy Bubal
ualaju шаци sajetap
PInOS 30L
SЧ.L
ssa saal J0 150g
pue aapung ar baum ep jo
KUIN TITI TROTSE
Ao pasd wg sow parn
In 01
MN DUR
BOLAS HES DUL CULTE
pua Aed jo seoj ou yan poon
D HOLS (acd par podes wd on sapa wonse outo
•ecode e nuên Supinduno 1830g
MON meedans
lado
Page 8 scan of this page
THE STREETS'
SEXUAL POLITICS
hand in hand with that for "gay pride"
to commemorate
time the gay fought back
Many of the men had been harassed for being conspicuous uate", and that was what forced them to begin the Debtback. A crond gatbered determined to free those arrested.
Only the arrival of reinforcements rescued the cops who were trapped in their van. The nest night hundreds of
people gathered on streets outside the bar and taunted the cops. Later in the week there was a Lating for an eni to basement. demonstrution for gay rights,
Stonewall was the rebirth of the gay movement Internationally. Nine years later, a large part of our work is concerned with fighting the attacks of the State, the boises, and the right. The Gay Pride march in London on 8 July will focus particutarly on the enormons intensification in police harassment of gays,
Bet as the nume Gay Pride Implies. the fight for gay more than defence against attacks: it also mewas organising to give collective sapport to individall gay people, to
Ip people come out as gay
vercome the self-haired that imposed on us
These "social" aspects of gry libera. lion are sometimes seen as secondary to the 'political' fight agaimt ruling class attacks, In fact, the two things are Inseparable.
The establinhment and delesce of democrable rights — which in the end can ouly be guaranteed hy a workers' state Is obviously a minimuin need lori social liberation. But there would not lie a struggle for clementary rights
some gays have the personal support secesary to come out as ga and light their victimisution. will scept bet lad of night? propie And without
The wims und content of the sochil
etivities of the gry movement depen
• our politiest situation, le is ther fore vital for socialists and the labour movement to support and where
necessary, defend gay counselling setvices, centres, and swit chboards than at any times noce fore nece This support is now
The crisis has given rise to a sharp
sease: a the
buglone ibe cupitalist wodd, and a
assequent streagthenine of
espect of our oppression as guys. The
basic abn attarks.
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 28 June 1978 page 8
'OUT OF THE
CLOSETS....
AND INTO
GAY PRIDE week 1978 takes place from 30 June to 9 July. Gay people in this country and internationally will demonstrate for gay rights and proclaim that gay sexuality is not something perverse to be hidden away, but that on the contrary, "Gay is Good'.
On these pages, we look at some aspects of the gay struggle now, and why the fight for gay rights goes
GAY PRIDE week is celebrated at this time of year
what has become known as the Stonewall Rebellion, writes JAMIE GOUGH.
In Greenwich Village, New York on 28 June 1969, cops raided the Stonewall Inn, a gay bar. But this
men and women who were arrested
mine sex rules, and thes of the family.
In Britain, the polices of the Labour Governient have laid the brasis for un overall deit to the righi, which is cideal in the attacks an gass an less than those an hlucks.
The Government has directs reinforced this trend by. Tor Instance, the refusing to allow time for the Bill liberalising the age of consent for gay men in Scotland: by championing of Whitehouse's Child Porn Bill; and.
Callaghan's disgusting campuigs for a strengthening of the Tamily.
Non-gay people are asked to support direct the demonstration on 8 July by marching behind gay banners. non-tay people can not only the fight fur the elementary political rights of guys, but also experience and solidarise with the daily social appres sion of lesbians and gay men.
July: Gay Teachers' group at Ovat House
Spoco. 7.30p
lalunday &July Assemble noon outside Sione Batue Sat f duls:
Sun 3 Jule: 1iam-üpm; An somning of poetry the star, Landon Ad, West Croydan. - i data # 07-857 7324
GA YSin Landon
Court area
demanstration demands police harassment,
reports,
and The forced to
Pub. in the almost nightly
acres them
over the country there seeite 10 malor offensive against pays;
BEETLICH prison for
between the ages of 18 and 21. most seriody.
WITCH-HUNTS
In this way Constable
SUD DUT
COULUT Again in arnests for public
doors or spend bours watshi Car Information from Gay
Moral purge
are hearing the brunt campaign of harassment from police, and the well established gay community in the Earl's
of Endan has been
But guys will not he forced back into the closets. Thisyear's Gay Pride Week
Run und will march through Earl's Court. NIGEL YOUNG
In Earl's Court, The Masquerade
Catacombs, two gay clubs. cinse following raids, Colcherne same arca. bas had an Police presence for the lastrwo years. Many gay men have heer arrested in the area; plain clothes police roam thesirees, pick up men and then
bopkshop has been forced to close and another shop in the
raided & gay in London
or kissing in public and been sene mu
relationslups with men
In Bradford and Cornwall there have been massive police witch-hunts. In Manchester the palice were considering Anderton's pubs in Earl's
marching with prosocuting a club under an Act against licentious dancing! This basn't been used in this country since the 19th
Anderkan's Lancashire, he speaks in public.
lavatories have gone nearly 200 percent. The police climb on roofs, spy through helen look under
More and more gays are relusing to plead guilty to charges of obstruction, TOM ROBINSON BAND at the Gay News demonstr
London
friend gay IM
• LLing importuning or gross indecency. And as police evidence is questioned, the extent of police harassment becomes obvious. The Gay Activists" Alliance is monitoriag police activity around the
and will be the Gay Pride demo through Earl's Court on & July
In Manchester too the GAA has begun to organise against Anderton's moral purge. He is picketed wherever
Itis vital that all cases of harassment and discrimination are not just fought by gays on their own hehalf, The police must be forced to account for their actions to all groups in society. The vagueness of the law in defending our rights, which allows the pelice so much tobin for nanoeuvre, mos be changed.
LIHA
ARE
ME
VA
Coming out
SINCE THE rise of the Ton Robinson Band, Glad to b Gay' has aimost become household refrain. It's still thi case, though, that socialists have not given muel thought to the question of ga politics,
As Gay Pride wee approaches again, i seems good time to give the matte some consideration, argue THERESA CONWAY.
At a first glance — looking at gloss macazines for instance — it seems tha ideas about heteroscxual sex changing. But once you begin to retle • bit bo't al straigh TOCHITE
The idea that sex can be pleasurabl "even for women is gaining som currency; but still many women neve have orgasms, Furthermore, sexuali active women have always existed, bu they are usuaily labelled "whores, un contrasted with passive women whi have dignity and innocence attribute to virgins. Both these sterootypes cri to please men and not much h changol!
Infidelity Is stüt more ampeptable lo mien. And sexuatity is still generall redaced to peuctrarion; very salistyi: for men, but for from enough t whens see enorment
CHALLENGE
The threal-poseil by gay pou deeply challenges bourgenis icol used more, bur herermesual relati ships are, in the long, term based
This validates ima
Page 9 scan of this page
TIOBE PROUD
OUDTO BE GRY
ROVDIV/HAPPY
OV HEPPY INWA YAY
cale relations in the cycs or society.
Such 'validation' doesh't exist for sex between tao men ar two women -it can only he for pleasure. A woman living on her own bringing up a child is seco us unfortunate and the objoc of pity. But two women living together as esbjans and choosing to bring children ure seen an a real scandal!
WHITEHOUSE
Changing leas about sexuality are far from universally accepted rowth society. for OrganISaTIOS the Protection of the
Unborn Child and the Festival of Light, and the success of Whitehouse's campaign News and for the Child Pornography Bill, shows how the right is gaining ground on these issues.
All the social moverents that have developed in the States and Western Europe since 1968 have heen quick to see the importance of ideology. They have recognised that self oppression is one form of social control: if you think you deserve to suffer, then you're not ikely to fight your oppressor.
In this way "Gay is Good' from the same souroc as Sisterhood is Powerful' or "Black is Beautiful", All teubet newbund posayc-ocanas uI oppressed people who are no longer prepared to see themscives as "quee's weak" or 'alien'
But for gry people there is an adde factor. ¡exual orientation is nol 4 Lact Inkeskin colour or biological sex. Gaye have to discover theit gayness pot an cisy tisk gisen the persuasive weight of hereroseal 'norms are people who have first "admitted" the tha te day? therar demate -TE B) 1 sixties
IT gay people are
ia a political sates
CHE
Fighting
Isolation
up
Two snippets
The
abuse is NEESOM, Mary Icebreakers, writes. against Gay
cloak Sometimes we reply in kind.
pary on tarnet experience.
BISLAALS
comes
Camen bennE Dur ethers who are facing ILSES
WOOLSEC EEn
criminal we dont tell them to accepr Cel Dr IO Pu just hecause they are gas.
There at the oppression of gays.
anil fight our Aboration i more iil ficul!.
RICCIE 'QUEER, bent and a sod'. 'l am the Eva Peron of Ilford',
from recent OUE E phonecalls to Icebreakers.
The first is the more typical.
common, PAUL whe works for
Sametimes we listen and try to go beyond it, to explore the motivations thal made them phone. It can often be
genuine anssely.
Knowing how ta reply is hased
I'm Sure make
We do not pretend to be experts. We are not councillors advisins people on theit problems. We are a collective of
ETALEEHLE LU isolation and
Mans of our-cellers — neary all of
scem surprised not to be told that they ure ill, perverted or
They are offen amazed thac second wilh being ignored
Weiry to encourage a sense af anger
Fichting the solation facine gays is the most crucs step Winniee support. tor the wider politica stuggle for gay
Soccers Is bard to measure. But the neca tor a pow- approacn to ocla
DAKIUE
So who phones? And low can we help? All ager and from all parts of the country, including transexunis sedophiles, whose sexualiy is put lown in the vilest ways We concern ouraelves wish practicalities not legal
otherwise we coult accomplish nothing
We can heip in giving encouragement and support in coming out.
SEL any call
psychiatrists, social workers or other
"help': thaugh similar services do
This is not bocause of the different kind of callers that they roccive. Ht is that they have a different understanding of gay oppression; not secing that the problems are structured into society and nood to be challenged
Ring Icebreakers any 7.30pms to 19.30pm on 01-274 9590. Or Gay Switchboord 24 hours a das on 01-837 7324
Hila Sae Bron
Rubyfruit
Jungle
Rubyfruit Jungle
A scarlet L'
on my
forehead
'MOLLY BOLT American, true-blue gay and proud of it!"
Rubyfruit Jungle's back cover. *A novel about being different and loving it!' sickeningly coy Capital Radio advert.
Worse still, the front cover features two long haired women embracing in the centre of a blooming white flower. what have they done to you? SARAH ROELOFS this widely discussed novel.
Publisbed for the first time in this
last March Rubyfruit Jungle was launched into the newly discovered highly lucrative feminist" market. Corgi say that to their surprise the
They worried about first, Happily it's now seling berter than an average popular Wila rood tant pune sa paperback,
Originally published in the United States in 1973, it became a 'leshian cult notel', Imported into rhis country hy the alternative Compeadium. acion Moverent loved and treasured it No feminist bookshell is ically complete without it Now It's hit the big time: the nass market
Carrie's husband bas syphilis and
unable to have him, She adopt» Molly. I thought you Minte ate melt Couperid Infuriated by Molly': unfentinine and Clever behavper Carrie tell her she B Weilti ato, Worcied but utrepentaot
ny reuect 1 really cont care. 1 pot myself born, that's what counts. I'm here.
Molly, independent, rong, cynical
a survivor. Molly, who on second reading is jast a bit too crude, too strang, too good to he true. Molly who neser compromises, never sells out and and somehow always keeps on lighting. Molly, an archetypal hero in a story book adventure.
When making love to women Molly thinks of their genitale as a rubytrus Jungle, -eldaco treasrcs. witn sucaa postve We description of women are trained in seif-hate, it is no wander CACI DELOBE SAVOE-SEINTE LUHE SLY For the book has given strong and brave and free no less, when all we have is the women-hating -TIELER HIMALL. 1 UE novels of tragic lesbians.
It has given us a woman who fought and while slogging away ar liberating ourselves Now we bave Molly who hits back every rosten shot fired at her: "Do you think you 're queer?" a best friend asks. Milly repliea t gs tate touce
wEar eblazoned acoss my chest. coula always carve a scarlet 'L' 00 mg forehend... I dan't know what lam -
plymorphous
CE IHE to he.?
Rubyfruit Jongle gives us laughter, exhilaration and a feeling that we can win too. Daughier of Farth is more faithful to the real horror of warmen's Heves, but too many af those books and we chn start wondering is it worth it?
We need stories like Rubyfruic to
oep us going
omelimes we'll be crying all thie Gim Rila Mae Brawn knew doing and her phrasenlogy is cool: 4 go wilking down the street and the mcD look mne Dsc a wikia sn receptacle.? Read il.
Kubyfruir Jungle by Rica Mae Brown
.. an all
annonces
said the
blonde
Rubyfruit, you gulp.
reviews
bry Corgi, Lesbian line EUBES
book has sold WETE ib "taboo subjoc!' at net woek.
acocpiance.
London bookshop the gay the Women's Liber
children by
Counse you
POSITIVE We lesbiunlsm
Line.
donations
thick and rich and fill
themseives, when
that Ruhsfruit Jungle has sent lo
us a bero-
at best faralistic
Use are painfully
label 'Queer' 0: 1
and perverse Shit.
Thai's ail 1 am and all 1 waet
if we don'l laugh
MYEIRLL SELO
LESBIAN LINE
01-794 2942
By women,
for women
LESBIAN LINE is a national phone service for women operated entirely by women, offering help. adviee and information. We do not see ourselves as experts. We are a group of women of a wide range of ages, hackgrounds and experience that we would like to share with other women.
provides an oppor for sharing information, making links between different groups already in existence, belping isolaled lechians and hisexual and encouraging the tornation of a wider
Society prefers to close its eyes to stie existence of leshians. But this apparent indifference is not to be confused with
There is general misconception, both inside and outside
moverent, thal becauss lechians are not overli discriminaled
law (unlike niale homovexuals), lesbial oppression is less serere and our strugale secondary to that of our gay brothers
As well as opeu prejudice against lesbiams, there iv no support available to mest women considering a leshian relationship. Instead they are told to work at their relationships with men.
offer a positive view al! wonlen contact us and communicate to them a sense of confidence.
We all work voluntarily for Leshiar
non-profit making organisation, financially dependent on
and fundraising, 30 financial helm 1s extremeiy WORDInE Both administration and phone duties ATE THETCE CELSI
We also bold small social gatherings to enable women 1o lak and eCt C0 know other leshians. Al present we are open lor auy woman who wants to ring 2-10 pM. and haesdays, oil Moodays and Fridays between
Wedoesdays and Thursdays 7-10 pm. Letters can be WoN xx, telephone: 01-704 2902 WD BM I London SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 1978 tage B
Page 10 scan of this page
USOWE
ganas popo srs.
faure jo sisonbar se pasonb
SaL 1 3S11B300 pomogo) sou are suogonau
saa no s Datao
stadi MuNDiN MuMiRi miLA un apog
Bununcooe wa and san
pue postua
4q-Jassed 148nt ut
MAAI OEU Sai SITO
stams tuy Кацт
Suy ap
pue uf decub Durany upan 9629 009 10101
LIEE
97 19 aqu
cue sses Bunuaw aul
snogn
spiay Tuind spunmes quog •peap sour sem ing
pausep saylo bal, H S73T SU1 TO
genua podas
Bam 10 10 108
panj цепоці
sappu!
asOE soa saa sass pas au
o suna sp
Suuy SUOMEIOEA
"waas waag
anăny #LSE
Ane l aug sy Sumte
12A2
ues pur payacunu
SGPS 062-60
= Un
TWEEPARNO
a91 jo Rugoos SHIBBE
sund
*TE3
зарічал Taupes
цим.
Cand sou punoj tew
isad
Teup put
Sut puna
peap
ppy Tupe
*,Kured 500T Jansu в рорлемв
socg nise! noes atested de
4000. ze00 oc-li soud
3041 Яшен. в0 puno sjam suno u0110.
You sEN E TAaNY aLEO mini3 S:DI0S
o3 Mow 05 weyt spunos
BULE. sopod pres
Zapu asjag apan ose prous
Каці :pasaddesip злам
pucsss SEM Joys sEM 'SL61 091
am ay te pomme sjappios пшод в рец
SEM
Amap
Ageng 01
15 T.
Kuped 00'G3
pansasoud 301
aed
4inog cosp
pause
DI SuaM. paumun paraqunu ino pue papunoums tap) pue paapusins foч.l
грипо: оог зало зер русь алеч paay aran. coppungnue jo
U00208 00 000 MOH1
(pinosge au
ONIGNNOM
Gap 10 равопиш
aue susany dunn jour suossad
Aurons 33118 S41- sayru
Cen mịy pịns suuy sựL
Sundi0zie
Ww EUDo aI In00E DTT
101 Suboous
OLL SASOY 4
So0eo ino ta Dun Doinai
weBoq шаци
àn n tin th tn tin Suns pur d sn. 34м.
S MA PARIDONEE SON SEM
(es
saa ou sp sap p INBONE
KG 27 S4L UMO 109 SOISS 30 1507
soar ory Nq —
An pun salo g s
san opas joas sapa
J0 sapta.
astenaq daay n to ten ton pa to ton. e salen spagdso preg oui
King ea 40E Amay + peop poq Киты за
valu o gua son ad D KayoW SO ous seM Do8
pres cognaco saale 94
Januas us00n TONS SEM ATO men peap sut Tei seM Ss0xa
mp sapon "ann 1
INOQE apodica
STELI, PIP 100 SONYIOIW
LOsR/ciRID HUL 91 30s1 pue dousp pool
(ooz ded)
Page 11 scan of this page
"Tanks are the main electors'
Internationalism lacking
third of the vote
seats) and a populist left wing.
parliamentary reforms.
Assembly to meet.
en route to exile in Sweden.
What do you think of the significance of the first partial
of the Constituent
Above all, I want to talk about the restrictions placed on these ECHOES
First, illiterates did not bave the right to vote which excluded some of the most conscious sectors of Peruvian society, likethe Indian peasants who do not speak the colonial language of Spanish
Thus, those who have carried out agrarian reform, increased production and bettered their standard of laving are treated a sub-human.
Then soldiers did not have the right to vote, in a country where the military junta rules the country 'in the name of the armed forces.
Finally, to have the right 1o
slates in the clections vor had to colest 400 signatures - a very high tigures.
You should know that the authorities did everything to impede their collection by the organisations which identified with the workers movement.
They continually stopped comrades who were collecting signatures in the street and stole the lists they had already got.
To top it all, ten days before the closure of nominations they refused FOCEP halt signatures, that 1s 20,000, The comrades, with preat persistTHE Soweto uprising of 1976 was not only heroic moment in struggle of the South African people against apartheid, writes JON HYSLOP. It also posed a threat 10 the British ruling class and economic interest South Africa.
So it was a poor rellection on
British len that the roccut SELUTU stration called by the African
La couple of bundred
But what was worse was that the Anti-Apartheid Movement (AAMI failed to mobilise even token support, despite the fact that its National Conunities had overwhelmingly voled to sponsor the demonstration
No member of the AAM icadership attended. Only one AAM group turned up its own initiative.
INTERNATIONAL
Interview with Hugo Blanco
the first elections since 1963 the parties of the workers" movement have won a
- a dramatie improvement on any previous showing.
The revolutionaries of FOCEP have taken between 10 and 13 per cent making them the third largest party. To add to the capitalists' troubles the majority party. APRA, is split between the right (which will have a majority of
The left's advances are part of the upsurge around the general strike at the end of May. FOCEP has made it clear that it will rely on that mass struggle and not
It has plans for a mass workers' and peasants" convention. One of the first tasks of that convention may be to force the military to allow the Constituent
It looks as though exiled deputies will not be allowed to return, and the regime may decide to ignore the election results altogether.
In this interview FOCEP leader HUGO BLANCO gives his preliminary assessment of the results. He was talking to the French Trotskyist daily "Rouge •
"WAST HEIR THE CRAEER TEAHITES of the FOCEP campaign?
Within FOCEP my organisation, the PST, stressed the fact HALL CHAS ELECTOIN its
African solidarity
march consisted of one line in the internal members' mailing. the The AAM had relused to back the ASU's call for a demo, as it was planning its own rally: The CHECHELL for changed the date and time of its rally. so. that people in attend both:
The AAM National Conmittee decided on this basis to support the demo, But the executive did nothine to carry i out the National Committo's Decision.
It seeins that there are two types of NC decision; those passed on the iniriative of the executice (which can be builti and those passed initiative of those of whom the executive disapproves (winch can be ignored). campaigl united and cifective unless a is id prepared accept ideas from all sections of Is membership on The executive shows hoscility many groups
THE PERUVIAN clection results have shaken the military regime to its roots. In debt, and a ency, got another 20,000 in a crisis of the rotten capicalist
system, political, social and coonomic structure is needed in s country:
This is why we elaborated a general draft of a constitution which included nationalisation without compensation of all industrial through at the moment is a cancellation of the HUGO BLANCO arrives in Paris from Argentina.
mobilising
could the
be
the movercat → in this case the three main backing the demonstration: the 01 Socialist Workers
ment at the same time.
popular
Wants and neighbourhoods.
recallable at any time.
dratt constitution
FOCEP:
ISt Revolutionary enterprises. the Party
foreign
and the
ternationul.
TUEYES
1960%
their purpose
Tunction? solidarily and ASU organisations
Party,
propramme of works, decided by the popula
workers. peasants and neighbourhood residents — to resolve the questions of unemployment and develop-
Of course, we explained that all these meissres could only be carried out hy a workers and
could only be based upon commiEces of workers, peas
added that the members of this gosernment Cold only CarD the same 35a worker and that they should be
The armed forces should be consistuted on the basis of the defence committees of workers, peasants, and so on. This
was battle horse in this campaign.
Moreover, we never stopped Forker: Peasants: Students (10-12 cent) People's Froat. Made up of struggle. four Trotskyist groups: Mars-
Workers (POMR), Socialist Workers Party (PST), Revolutionary Left Front (FIR-POC)
Socialist Struggle water. group. The first is tied in the port.
Communist Organisution in Frunce. The
others support the Fourth in
• FOCEP also inclass strupele
groups within the trade unions. (there
LDP: (2-3 per cent) Popular Democratie Union. Made up mainly of Maoist groups, hut also involving some supporters
of the Fourth International.
PSR: (6 per cent) Revolutionury Socialist Party. Despite its
fraud mume the PSR claims to represent the politics of the leftist' millars recame or for dar
explaining that these elections were an clecioral farce and that there should be no illusions in
the
In this couniry tanks are the main electors, even if they are illiterate and can't even speak
How did the FOCEP campaign
The recent history, and even the | bloc of four cinsses.
THE TO GO HOME International Marxist Group
The AAM has support from relations. labour movement dignitaries and other celebrities and there
'The land balonos to those who work it. - 098880 demonstration in Peru.
not so recent, of the country shows that the gains of the workers can only be maintained through their organisation in
So each FOCEP committee had to be organised within this perspective. For example, in one neighbourhood it organised the struggle for drinking
electricity, and trans-
A FOCEP support committee in a factory would mobilise the warkers for the general strike, for specific demands a the plant level, and for thi rehiring of the sacked workers
were 5000 after the general strike of 19 July 1977)
That's why we consider our vote as a voic for social For PSR the organisation and mobilis ation of the masses for struggle, as a vote against the electoral
two electoral fronts and not
For aur part we were ready to gointo the UDP coalition from
start, OLEL Maoist comrades who had hegemony
UDP made precondition of acceptance of their goverantental formula: 'a revolutionary popular government" which, as we saw it, was nothing but the concretisation of the Macist concept of the
RUDESIANS MAŞE BLACKS MI ZAMBIA! is a lear that involvement with f
uselul → but only as a step to orgamising action
able to collect the necessary 40,000 signatures we called for a critical vote for the UDP.
FOCEP had three i centri planks in its platform: independence of the class, struggle agninst che governe enlar strugglestion and
On top that, cach organisation participating in FOCEP could develop its own programme, which seems to us a correct conception of running an electoral campaign.
In our opinion the comrades of the UDP leadership looked a little too closely towards what burgeoie and her see called the progressive alternative, When I said that, I EDYEInmEnLa was treated like a splitter..
When General /Leonida:
came back tom exile for the electoral campaign he was on television one time just before me
He insisted that the PSR would defend small and medium property and absol ately did not want to divide the armed forces
1 could only explain, when my turn care to speak, tha these soldiers of the first peniod of the military junta afler 1965, as progressive, didn't hesitate to open fire on people as soon as things got tough...
The AAM must pot see its MELL WILL LOCUSCATE important than with those who are prepared to fight here and
SODIALISE CHALLENGE e3 June B8rd
Page 12 scan of this page
Gulag in the French CP
The long road to East European solidarity
inside the party.
festival organised by the PCF's youth "Avant-garde'.
member the
FOR the leadership, it was not the political perspective which gave birth to the crisis of the PCF, nor the TCHS 10 open. 8735155011 forums in the Communist press — it was the ill feeling of a few "intellectunis'..,
INSULTS
It was already apparent in The Marchais Central Committer: imprecations and insults blossomed there for no BONUSUA reason (petty-bourgeois anarchists* lectuals seated behind their desks'), alongside disconcerting replies to questions refuted all the more casily in that they were made up out of nothing and attributed always to anonymous comrades.
lous ac neo up tor u scorn of the militants "those years later.
Eastern Europe Solidarity Campaign.
RICHARD CARVER
, did the Eastern ENTODD Solidarity Cumpaign start and what are its airasi
Discussions about forming a united cocaist Campa m
olidarity with people suffering
oppression in Eastern Europ
stumber the ar
A number of participatine dhel erent
deas of what the plasform of tbe campaign The main difference whether all repression should be defended or woeter there Show De all element of discrimination.
Some people argued that groups that seek to propagate
lead to the restoration capitalism SOUL IKOL
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 1978 page 12
INTERNATIONAL
THE leadership of the French Communist Party (PCF) has pledged that it will not use the traditional weapon of expulsions to resolve the present crisis
But its domination of the apparatus gives it plenty of opportunities nevertheless to suppress discussion and intimidate critics. Opponents of the leadership from the Union of Communist Students (UEC) in Bordeaux were even physically attacked at the recent
These methods were highlighted in an article which appeared in last week's issue of the French magazine "Le Nouvel Observateur'. Below we reprint the bulk of this article, written by SERGE LEWISCH (a
UEC in Paris) and ROUCAUTE ( a PCF member from Arcueil).
everything, no matter what" chose who want factions and that the masses "can organise spontaneously those who 'attack the full-time officials and, still more dishonestly, those who have chosen' to express themselves outside the party. As if they had had any choice!
STYLISTIC The way this mapped out, but pursue it. Our national intel- as certain militants say bitterly among themselves has 3inco socot 1s time in hipping up the atmosphere LILLIANE increases stylistic amalgains: Althosser Elleinstein = Garandy the Socialist Party Threats follow I presence of Elleinstein
Interview with Vladimir Derer
WHEN VLADIMIR DERER arrived in Britain in 1939 as a political refugee from the Nazis he cannot have imagined that he would still be here nearly 40
He had been a member of an opposition group inside the Czechoslovak Communist Party, and prudently decided not to return home when the CP seized power. The trials of the 1950s saw the bulk of his old comrades Imprisoned or executed by the regime.
In Britain he joined the Labour Party and is secretary of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy. He is also convenor of the recently formed
talked to VLADIMIR DERER about the campaign and the problems of the defence of democratic rights in Eastern Europe.
suppurted.
The Labour Party members, IMG. SWP and Party look the position victins of repression should he defended and this position that was eventuall adopsed:
groups One of the main arguments against the position adopted by
Defending ull victims гергеніна sou play into hunk of the ticht wine who seek overthrow post-capitalist social relations in Eustern Europe. How would You answer thalr
1 should say first that the of Compagn does position on the class character
Althusser at cerlain debates becomes "unacceptable". worst slanders are aired: The comrades who the party are bought by che bourgeoisie" (as one councillor
With L'Humanite and certain men from the apparatus, is happening as if the leading paper. faction hoped to
impossible to pose political GUES ONS
CONDEMNATION YVES To do this, it has just taken a
further step in bolstering its practices: it is mounting trials, political trials. In dozens of section committees hundreds of cells, "they"
DELEINE I0 D condemnation of the letter of Tartare BEELER. as a factional which challenges the party and it's political line.
The general, the text is drawn up by
Committee. or by leader. It is then vote at the levels below. When the result is positive, there is nothing more to do but let it wing its way to L Humanite. And all this happens without those having had any knowledge of
itS the form and content of what
they without
compose OUCH TO TIES. SHE WORSE. without the accused heing able some members that all
the
of the Soviet Union and the Eastern European states Personally I take the view irrespective thut characterisation of those states
it is impossible for socialists 1o
the exert any
influence in Bastern
the without taking
manifestations of opposition to the regimes.
If we fail to do this, the tield is open to people who may seek
have relations. In this sense people
F who argue that discrimination
The
write outside
assistance
, everytring reach the are
TENSIOLE
undertaking leaderships':
is sameer
tbe
federal put to the TOE abroad. cunrades
country.
The accused condent ever
condemn, knowing the reasons happening
Czechoslovak and publish texts 'Charter 77,
are trying of wish to avoid
effective political lavers of the
Europe movement European close.
and the
capitalist social value: the
lo delend theniselves in the paper read by Communists
At the time of Scalin also, Communist parties ensured the condemnation of certaio their members who described
their confidence the real conditions
I He and of struggle in the
Were. Condemned on the strength of countries. abbreviated doclarations by the unaninsous leaderships of the Commurist parties. This is sill scandaloos
today with the signatories af whose delence has, however, been taken up
IE.- should
in the CSSK movement
nationally.
Ir's
must be the basis for solidarity are helping those elements who
TO can only objective that they claim they
En Britain the association of
supported by with the Eastern Teginies
Ir's the Thatcherite argument experiment
claims of Soviet propagunda taken at their face
ITIE more repressive CATES ATTRE DOVICISTALLI UPAS are seen as the embodiment of
YVES ROUCAUTE (left] and SERGE LEWISCHE: We must cease having a blind confidence in our
Communists should 1 recall and ponder on what that means. We must cease naving i blind confidence. Being can to our leadersaps. it military itust be replaced by a critical
it is time to asseis for ourselves what is meant by the criticisms addressed to the Teaderships of the "socialist — to anguish and despair-
That is why all Communists who agree today to sign these
condemnations are, uL ou vica, accompaces of the Gulag. For the Gulap is the Avant-garde tesaral,
simply the exerination of all those who utter criticisms gutside the party and aside it,
chiss socialism. Very few people in
It is therefore important for the shour morencat here that
absolutely disms sociate itself from the negative features of the political system
That's oblonsis one aspeci
presentation alternative model of socialisa But the dominunt tendencies British Labour from
have heen the cally Communist Party and u lahour hureaucracy which has been
pro-Soviet interWhen the issue is Chile. say, or South Africa it's easy in a routine way to push a resolation through your labour movement brunch. It's a bir different when you're talking ahout Eastera Europe.
La questibe of explanation of oppression of individuals or social groups
The official attitude within the trade unions and the higher echelons of the Labour Party
influenced by pressure from below. to take the issue up, and this is many people at the branch level who are very STELLELIE what they regard as a socialist
At the time of the inception
BUSILE same British goverument that offensive agairat the working
it is aiso a state of mind and the methods which lend to il.
The Gulag, as extermination camp, is only the end resuit oi a certain practice, of a Stalinis
iselation which driven orlain comrades wo had devoted their life to an idea — a classless society and freedom
Ir is a practice of amalgam, lies, ever violence, as is shown by the blows struck against the Bordeaus comrade:
Gironde lederation ofticials, at
When one tolerates, covers up for that. the yes, the Gring 1 is not so far off
was offensive against the
he for ten te durin
propaganda exploited the absenE -of uncouployment, while evervone could see tbe
West.
The rise of fascism was linked in people's consciousness with che ruling classes in the West and the Soviet Union wasseen as the bulwark against
it That's a matrer for debatt
but that show people tended li see it.
That was confirmed daring the war when the Soviet army had to carry for three years the major burden in the military conflict.
Thesc attitudes survived long after the war. To change the attitude of the rank and file w's have to familiarise them with TIE TANES
If this information, which a be quac accurate, come
the presE 0r Ton politicians then it is automati
dismissed Tory propaganda.
There should be a credible
from socialists, This is the basis
Solidarity Campaign.
* You can contiet the EESC
STEVE.
NWIT The campaign has brought out its first brieting on
Soviet Trade Union посвині ша вст воо movement (modies to pass resHaucas in support of these unofticial unionists and to situate to the catalen
The EESC is planning a mujor conference and demon. stratiot on the tenth anniver-
Warsew Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia in
There will also be a concert organised in conjune-
Rock Against Racisti
The campaign needs u lot of money to put on that sirt of event, so send donations to the above address.
Page 13 scan of this page
The rats are beginning to kill each other
Chilean crisis
1978 relatives of political prisoners
Tanding ere were
demanding know
whereabours or fate of their
relatives. As Pinochet's recent general amnesty extends to the
secret police (DINA/CNI), the
relatives have no recourse to
Even if they can demonstrale that the DENA took their
away amnesty has already pardoned The Dolsee - 50 there is no crime to answer for!
The postponed for 30 days after Pinochet would give information ahout everyone who has disappeared,
SOLIDARITY
The 30 days expires on 8 July and already the junta his denied that made promises to the relatives. further solidarity actions will probably be necessary:
The origins of the hunger strikes are to be found in two sets of events apparently quite unconnected the disappear-
murder Orlando Lether
On September Letchcr, a former Minister in Allende's government, killed by a bomb in Washington DC.
A vear before the Lettier
the Committee for Peace of the Chilean had TENTLE Chilean Supreme Cour Inquiry into
disappearance Teftists the
made no response but coincidentally a minor Brazilian paper O Dia and an Argentinian magazine Les published reports that the 119. had been internal left-wing fäction fight and in clashes i Argentina with the police.
The Chilean press gleefully scized on these reports with the headline, The rats are tre. ginning to kill cach other".
WHERE
ARE
THEY?
WEWANTE
TO KNOWE
THE
TRUTH
A solemn MARCH FOR THE 2500
Each marcher carrying a white carnation-
SUNDAY JULY 9TH
IFE ANUFREEDOL
INTERNATIONAL
ON 21 September 1876 two explorers raised the Chilean flag over the Magellan Straits. On 22 May
"disappeared began an indefinite hunger strike in Santiago against the Chilean dictatorship. CHRIS KOSEBLADE asks: What links these two events?
cast light on the truth of these reports: i was discovered that magatine Leu was subsiby Argentina and that O Dia was not a minor Brazilian paper one and only publication been that devored to this very "scoop!
Le Monde then discovered general that several of those supposedly killed in Argentina had heen last seen at the time of was DINA who indeed admited inat they wore in castody, full In November 1976 FASIC tan independent body of the Chilean Church) released stati onl detainees: totalled 1400. considerable reduction on the Amnesty International reports any This reduction in numbers could not be explained either by the number of prisoners serving short sentences, nor by those who had commuted their sentence to exile. Morcover, a wave of kidnappings beginning.
DIPLOMATIC 1976 By 1978 the formal lifting of the 'State Siege was *General Amnesty', the com mutation of many sentences into exile, the release of 224 political prisoners es of a new draft Constitution church had resulted in an diplomatic offensive by the junta to repain international mass The political prisoners with criminal offences process as the Church usually aus to defend such prisoners.
There were only two prob. lems outstandine. the prearcd and affair.
It was a this moment tha the US Deputy Secretary of State presented a letter to the Chilean Supreme Court from is US cquivalent requesting that two men be interviewed in Bur cerain facts began 1o | coanection with the Letelier DISAPPEARED PRISONERS IN CHILE'
the hunger strikers" symbol for their missing relatives
Orgo-ketbrile Oil Soldanly Campoo IPSemeSses Road London hi Tel: 2724238
OR CHILE'S DISAPPEARED PRISONER
who have
altair in the presence of a US investigator.
The men were named fascists Williams
Alciantro names which puzzled several experts on Chilean mincteenth century history as they were who, one hundred years to the Letelier, had Chilcan flag on the Magellan Straits!
DINA'S ended when the photographs
of the two men were simultan cously published Wushington Mercurio in Santiago (which is which known to have close links with This was intelligence
The men identified as Michael Vernor Townley and Armando FerTHEY LATIN say, the shit had hit the fan
CAPTAIN Larios was a serving Captain was in the Chilean Army? Coinci-
dentally he had just been given leave for a long holiday when the sory broke!
Townley was a nobody - an electronics engineer the for an American h
"coincidences" seemed to dog his life toot and promi- He was quickly identified as overall Libertad - a leading member of Parria 3
Dirls. Not just that wanted for blowing sation in March 1973 and murdering a night watchman during the raid. had aided this Most embarrassingly of all it
мая soon May 1976 he had been wpriing on a case involving the tracing Letelier disa- of a right-wing Cuban lertor ist: a case not being handled by
the authorities - but the US Federal Bureau E8лоD The juma new story. The men had indeed used Chulean passports the records showed that aisports in question had beer ssued to a mother and child, going one but it was not the Therefore unlals responsibility sody a responsihle By a remarkable come. denice, the
those passports had committed suicide within Letelier's murder.
A few doubting Thomases had questioned whether this was at fact suicide but no one had paid them aily heed.
SCANDAL
Tel it was perhaps strange that che inquest had ascribed death to 'heart failure withour unking that Taure' to the teport of a The official had last been acco leaving a reception at the
Peruvian Embassy in the car of
'Colteras
head of DINA — the Chilean
secrer police.
The councidences began to
crowd cach other thick
fast Within an hour
discovery of the official's body
General Forestier (an intimate
al Contreras and Pinochet)
visited the family and persua-
ded them not io
much fuss about the suicide.
Even by the standards of
Rose
Romeral Jara
planted the
hooe of a cover-un
in
Post and
services).
BUILAL
and, as they working in serics
the Clulean fascist
discovered that in
junta.
serics Christian of Investi-
i came up with a and Townley
Trom Chile -but the
bead of Contreras.
cover-up mes Townley
Some- expulion gave the Consulate was
Armly Captain).
CRISIS
a month of
lying down.
quickly revealed that he
equipmert
On turther
bullet
tien of. President Contreras WiLs
Pledge
tunately and of the expulsion from the
braud?
make too Generals"
Chile today this was a scandal. Divisions opened ap within the
duced
General Leigh dropped bis old fascist fends and made a
critical speeches the crucial Democra! leader Forces, the 'Scate of Siege" was lifled ольстро
was expelled to thie USA quick
Ever this was not cuouet: the price of the Gelleral" support for Pinocher was the
HIS by 00W obviously the scapegoat. His
the USA victim and took the pressure off Contreras and Larios (tbe
movement.
His wife did not take the Santiago. bons.
Having at first
denied that lie was anything sighred With but an electronics engineer, she
had arrested made several tries to the USA to bury electronic surveillance
for the forces and thar he bad worked on other matters with the FBI
questioning She revcaled thar Townley was one
the leaders of the DINA
El Mercurio then revealed that the equipmen Townles had perchased in the USA bad neen tor the persomal protec-
Pinocher.
The junta denied all knowoh Towne regular trips Unfor25] reason they had given for his Also
country had been atrepular trips a on May
What ensued was the most serious crisis the recome had ever faced. At a molling of the
Council a motion asking Pinochet to resign was
uhly lost by 13 vates to 17,
A Cabinet reshuffle pro-
majority civilian cahinel although Pinochet's
posts Delencel. the
Divisions were beginning to
within the Generals.
The Navy seemed to Tavour a
reluTE barracks, sections of the Army seemed to favour a "trazilian' solution, others remained hard liners and gave Contreras a standing ovation on the day of his duughrer's wedding although official sources went to some pains to deny this.
The splits within the Gener als gave confidence to the mass
On May Day, despice the ban on demonstra-
5,000 marched 10
incredibly shortbrutaL ty the police people the Dutch trade unions.
The mass movement wa Intercontinental Press
DOCUMENTS fran the discussion in the French Communise Party are printed in the latest issue of Intercontinal Press/laprecor [Vol 10, No.
featured are interview with Daniel Bensuid
68. Why Curter is Shouting at Castro', by Joseph Hansen; un analysis of the lux
CENE USA: examination of the process of "de-Mucisution" in China, and • further mulerial Encluding an
stirring again: it culminated in the hanger by the relacives of the disappeared. This was Ence to ComI with the arrival in Santiazo ol an AFL-CIO delegation...and
American head of th
*Letelier avestigating team
It would he foolish to make hasty the Generals' speedy demisc Bul despile cverything resistance is sirring and the Generals are in internal crisis — the fruits of their internal brutality and jaternational isolation.
Sucialists must step-up theiz fighs in solidaricy with the Chilean people because concessions by the regime might bring for diplomatic recog nition.
Recognition, the legitimation which goes with it and the financial aid to the economy it would involve, would stabilise the dictatorship for a mud longer period than now seems possible.
That is why the hanger strikes are so important
combined win imprecor
inferview on the successful campaign 10 free Hugo
Single copies ure 10p plus mAD, but why not tuke adsan tape of the favourable suhseri issues], ES for six months |24 issues], introductory offer of 10 issues
Write now to Intercontinental Press/Inprecur PO Box 50. London N1 2XP. All cheques. POs should be mude nut to Intercontinental Press.
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 197B page 13
Page 14 scan of this page
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE EVENTS
COMMENT
Alternative
road to
socialism
MALCOLM KITSON (letters, June) informs as of a devastating truth: "Surely the main point af John Ross's letter (4 May) is that the debate on the Morning Star can only be taken up through a critique of the political
and orientation CPGB.
But every Socialist supporter who is active in the trade knows this. What we need an swer to tac question: now relate to the crisis in the CPGB and assist the develonment current moving towards revolutionДУ ПОЗНАЕ!
The British far left has traditionally had a one-sided view of the CPGB: that i H 'counter revolutionary through and throught, will always betray, etc. But even Trotsky, softy on Stalinism, rejected such a simplistic approach:
"They are a very contradictory phenomenon. They began October as the base, become deformed. but
We can't -antipathies of our moral feelings sway us. I think that we can hope to win these workers crystallication of October TY DE2S 1939-40, 0. 26M
in the meantime, from Yugoslavia to vietnam. socialist revolutions led by bureaucraof the world revolutionary process on Ine LPOB has beco lo te-emphasise the point that many CP militants identify with socialist revolution but between this ideal and the party's caught the reformist domestic programme
What can Socialist Challenge do in this situation?
«one of the main weaknesses in
holitical armoury of the left has been the lack of a concrete action sperm the socialist policies round
out the socialist policies around which the workers movement should unity. Such plan counterposed to the reformist British Road and used to create a much hroader political audience for our ideas.
Secondly, we have seen Socialist Unity draw individual CP members into action. We should seek to extend this by involving CP groups in joint itervention around delence of the closed shop the Tribunal on Britaia's Presence in Ireland, and so on. In particular, the Kudoll Bahro Detence Campaign provides an excelient opportunity for building a massive campaign against the Stalinist bureaucracy's usurpation. of democratic rights.
la this way we -assemble dissident CP elements and independents around an alternative strategic road to socialism. NOEL HIBBERT (Hall)
NORTH WEST
Socialist GREATER MANCHESTER Sociallet
58c SCBH
315a6 6, Contacted Dy ringing LIVERPOOL Spele Socialst Chal.
Noah's 4rc pub, Specs.
Liserenal SOm Chaing a. He SOUTH MANCHESTER Challenge perver 11 SCam and 1pm
rooshopping cent 25 mation 197 061-236 LONDON HARROW Socialist Challenge sup-
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 June 1978 page 14
BAD TASTE:
CORMAC
of the
Challenge Time for
movements
Can we
forthcoming with time before
they have
have
began as International, British Section)
seen cleven
'industry'
contradiction
have Joined the May
agaiest everything
with its super-heroes.
could be seemod
militant".
institutions of
Internationa
women's movement, the can begin 1o
whether Marxism 1s accept these movements
the critique
Po aex 50, Lend GREENWICH LEWISHAM Socialist WALTHAN FORESTED BE stew London E1?
ONDON CPSA Socialist Challens aders. We aro oslablishing a CPS
sompathelle to Socialies Challange: ideas write to concen SD organiser.
DID PO Box 53. London NI HACKNEY Socialist Challenge au
vare marching lor po CAMDEN Sucialist Challenge
TCH 11-0m 12-5 p:
1 11 Hi
PLEASE IGNORE THE
comment
but
IN YOUR positive article on the
Amnesty report Northern Ireland th June), you say that Amnesty have been trying to Keen secret the Tenort. Your readers should realise that all Amnesty
governments concerned for comment (and hopefully action) a considerable need
publication. In this
exactly the same consideration as the
many RICHARD ABRAHAM (Amnesty
The May '68
1 AM disappoipted to see that you (25 May). Can't you see that it goes
that 10% look part in May 66 were fighting for to turn it into another super-event
In fact, the spectacle of May '68 l more or less irrelevant. It is the ideas that were and are subversive, and
Socialist WE Challenge about them. Ideas Like: * The relation between the personal and the political; which questions the
practice of being
* The relationship between
out society and alietnatives. For example, the free school movement,
alternative psychiatry, the free radio stations in
May
Finally the relationship between the revoluticars oceaniation and the autonomous movements — the
TOUCHE gay black movemeat,
prepared to
mate, but rather for us to see what remains of traditional Marxisat after
made by these 00815490203
HUODERSFIELD Socialist Chai
HACKNET bOCIeSE Challenge
YORKSHIRE None on Chry Backerel Walmgato Thuradays
на апсикі спанапни огаш MOUCH Ans cn group or the bullesin irosvenor Terrace, Tock
movements of Marxist teary practice has been analysed digested,
Tariq Ali's analysis of the period very predictably mourns the lack of a revolutionary party.
the absence revolutionary party has got little to do with 'a correct strategic line...that would have made inroads into the base of the Socialist Party and the Communist Parly.
It has much more to do with the uneasy relacionship between terolutionary organisation and movements that are the vanguard of the struggle in Europe today; many revolutionaries today question the
for an overall political organisation.
Together with heroic victories over US imperialism, May 68 showed
of us the possibility
Is most important contribution was to make us question all the accepred doginas of revolutionary Marxisti. It should bot be Turned museum-picce only to be whecied out in a spectacular manner every ten
PETER ANDERSON (Manchester Big Flume)
The
yawning
gap
OBJECT strongly to introductory remarks in your article on the fascist rampage in Sputalficids (15 June): "The speaker was a white woman in her Fifties. appearance suggested a resident of Alf Garnett country' What the hell you intend to convey is unclear
Did you mean a middle-aged white working class woman. probably
With a bre ac showing a hard life. We don't recall being described as residents of All different about this woman? CUTLE What's
Socialist Unity bas paigning in the area for over a yoar now, nollbe around 30 per cent 0 the vote in two elections.
population of Spiralfields.
from white people in our work in the
NORTH EAST
Socialist Chai
110. 3am
DARLINGTON Nei-hern:
MIDOLESBOROUGH Challenge
also availasia
NEWCASTLE
SOUTH/WEST
Acos Ee. Post Orice, Burgan PORTSMOUTH Sucialist Cammercial Road Precinci
LEMBEDELE INSANE REPUBLICANS TRYING TO PISCREDIT
LEIC are the a polled an average ol
and about 80 votes — less than
cent!)
We are now establishing paper sales on the local estates, frequently elling to white workin (thet) and women who must, if we dare sel
the paper, read of themselves as 'Alf Garnett types*:
There sometimes seems to be a
eard and the betting che Ental
lers of general politics, but in an social a member of the working class, or
work with and among it You can ser this reaction again when the same article quotes a woman as saying. "If you wanted to be a Nazi, you were vibrant anti-fascism mingling with national chauvinistr" of Why should the morally bound to dissociate lumsell tracket? This remark seems to tako from it adding the worst possible understanding of a phrase which very likely did not have anti-Cierman national chaurinist sentintents, rejection of Remember it was we in ant-lascist movement who pinned the label "Nazi on the NF DAVID SPEAR.
LITTLEWOOD, MALCOLM HEYWOOD (Hackney)
*Disgusting
regrettable
the
and
irritating
whose
AS ONE OFine contributars to your Fighting Fund, I find it disgusting. reprectable and imilaing that you find Alexander Solzhenitsyn persistent and courapeous (8 lune).
Solzhenitsyn is noching but a pest who is dead set agains. revolution. The prool of this is that he chose Finland as a place for exile If he is a trac revolutionary.
A fair
why does he not stay in the USSR? and we
HASAN ABDULLA (Heading)
While we share our reader's feelings For dema Poneb- Coltages
Rock on
on Saturda
socular Challeng
fran newsagertt is Linthorpo Swel
Socialist Challenge
mupporter SOUTHAMPTON Site Camera
11.30am le 1pm
class men
forcibly hureaucracy!
for
reporter Icel
tac piece
but was Trorsky
fascist thuggery,
the
and
JENNY JONES, on condition effective.
CLOTHESE
towards
sary
covered tbrough
However,
disease
interess then SCOTLAND Fornic megan about the caper or
Challenge
DUNDEE: tomationston Socialist
of Retorm Steel sace Saturday, 11am-2pm SOUTH/EAST
about Solzhenitsyn's current activities, this description of him ma contained in a document by Soviet disidents which we reprinted. referred to his role in uncovering the details of the massacre of working
the regime in 1962. Moreover, there is a SEN SUNDIC TEEDE ME does not remain in the UISSR: he was
expelled by LEE
Cruelty
humanity
CONTRARY TO what wai Stated in the letter on the 'exploitation" fick of animals under capitalism (15 Junel.
did mention vivisection in his writings -he was firmly in favour,
This is a logical extension of both
Lenin's perspective torals, summarised in the famous cliche Be end justities the means
that the means are The second hall of this DEECE forgotlen but irovides the Key to ine interprentio
animals arc unnecessary For example, socialists condemn the production of cosmetics not hecause of toxic tests on animals hur hecause such produce are socially unneces
and superfluous. (The myth of technological "neutrality has beer
in Socialist Challenge SULE nuciear powcr.) Likewise, all produce from the whale and scal trades can b manufactured sunthetically
live antmas in medical rescarch are care 11 vivisection can take bummite on step searer to its ukamate goal of
conquest or contraceptives develon ment then iris worthwhile
We are revolutionary Marxists, not liberal moralisers, If the means cat effectively assist in achieving the end they are justified. To
of animals before thc teress al humans headlong into the pit of bourgeois
MICK MARSHALL (Oxford)
CHICHTON Sucast Challenca sala WALES CARDIFF Saclalist Challenge For
RaNd The Sir-sge r
MELANDS
roughoul Ire Midland
LEICESTER Socialist Challenge ments text on Thunde *a, -enlie ca Communily Contr 7.30pm prompt, NEIR
Page 15 scan of this page
The Gaullist guards
"Palestine'
promises
until 1948.
by eyewitness
WARD reports.
producers have a problem. A major factor in the creation of the state of isracl in 1945 was the expulsion of the Palestin-
But with one exception, no film is available to portray this enforced exodus.
It is left to ex-British Army officers to relate how Arabs Jaffa and Haifa "It was a
the come as to and they tele!
With Israel established, many of these Arabs would never be allowed home; those that did would not even be able to till the land they once owned.
SURFEIT
There is a
fresh-faced Zionist idealists setting out to reclaim' the land; there are no films of the Palestinian farmers who had tilled the soil for centuries. many important facts Palestinian case do cinerge in the commentary.
The main failings of the documentary lie elsewhere. The programme consists of ments of the views of various protagonists; It 15 NOt, as Thames TV claims, a debate on the Palestiman question.
For the Arabs, thir appears as a simple one. They have owned and worked a land for centuries - HOW TREY not conquered but expelled from their homes and land. To justify their practice, Zionists are forced to use i different kind of argument.
They claim Palestine for the Jews today by virtue of the history of their hiblical co-religionists. Starting this time, the Zioniss claim the
were forced Palestine by the Romans, longed everalter lo return and have been al the mercy of anti-semitism ever since.
The claims of the Jews and Arabs proceed it two different levels, so this revision of Jewish history and accommodation to anti semitism go unchallenged, In adition, much use is made 1
UNDER REVIEW
Le
Sherif
Britain's incompatible
AFTER TWO years" research, Thames Television is presently screening its documentary "Palestine'. In three instalments, it is being networked nationally and covers the period of the British mandate from 1918
Extensive use is made of archive film, supplemented
accounts and the views of two historians, one Arab and one Israeli-Jewish. NIGBL
Even at this stage, the | of film of Nazi Germany and
Many Arabs and supporters Palestinian case will think this not anty excessive. sightforward Zionist propaganda.
HOMELESS But the holocaust did have a profound effect psychology on Western opinion.
CALCERE We who advocate Palestinian case should attempt to understand wus prenome non rather than convenienuy dismiss N, as Me are enco to do in the past.
By refusing a confrontation of Arab and Zionist cases and WISTE historical period, the effect of the 'holocaust" film is simply to induce pity. The vieweris left to pity the unfortunate Jew and the homeless Arab.
Or, as the British politician Lord Peci reporis: " fundamentally a conflict right with right, Promoling the such a view allows the Zionists to escape the burden of their
the
case
ILTL front
from PALESTINIANS forced to flee in 1948.
times and Icads to the belie hat the Arab-Israeli conflict i insoluble.
One point that is striking in Palestine is the British role. Incompatible sell-government are made to Arabs and Jews alike in an colonial interests. The uses Arab hostages, including the Mayor of Nablus, in front
huildings to discourage Arah BLLACKS. Arab houses are indiscrimi nately blown up because there was nothing else we could do Portraits of the British colonial administrators almost turn into
course. newsreels of the time could only spew forth about the rotten lot of poor old Tommy.
There are other in Palestine. Leadine Palestin
on Jewish Hostie, who were Involve in deals with the Zionists and other with birdle criticism of their complicity and ineptoess. ARGUMENTS
While these programmes are a scrious attempt to deal with
subject. limited prior analysis of their adversary if they are to use the faces and arguments that are preseated.
The first part of Palestin was shown on Tuesday. second part is mext Tuesday, 4 July, And the third part at the same time on 11 July
there variations In
CARVER.
Boisset (interviewed on page), suggests that this because the magistrate prontises of
British army YVES BOISSET
weaknesses
like the EI
notables LSLUDI
with SAC alterwards.
anti-Zionist
certain happening in French
inspired by the
10.30pm to midnight.
thai.
but check to
regional
transmission
Not
which it i applied.
world, and underworld
SAC this amused me) cops.
who had to be
bleeped out
films in recent history.
It is based upon the true story of the murder of an investigating magistrate in Lyons, writes RICHARD
Tbe film's director, Yves
Service
Interview with
Boisset
Tell me about why you made Le sher and me me
I made Le Sherif to examine
things which. society. happened in ONENTONER murder of Why?
District Amorney Renauu m Lyon, but I didn't want to make a film specifically about
There are, anyway, a lot of differences between the film and that case, the most miner world, of which is that Renaud was in his 50s and Patrick Dewacre, who plays Fayard, is not yet 30
What 1 had in mind was
petting into question certain
ideas about justioe, just as the young district attorneys are now doing drougbout France.
questioning justice itself, exactly, but the ways in
the process of putting the film cogether, I learned a good deal about the connections between worlds which are supposed In , be separate in our society: the business world, the political
the criminal
I learned a lot about the connections of all of that with certain conservative elements in
- a riefit-wine. parawhich
was supposed to be defunct,
When the film was finished.
we were taken to court by SAC
obviously not defunct
who claimed we had defamed
them; that we had suggested shooting.
they were all either not-too flat on
bright criminal types or (and
LE SHERIF is one of the most controversial political (SAC), the Gaullis paranti
stumbled upon a conspiracy of right-wing politicians and the underworld, cemented by the
d'Action Civique
the The
The court decided that we had to take out all references to SAC in the film. Instead of reshooting or redubbing. WC just bleeped out each mention of SAC with a sound.
The film is based on a case that
yet you
There were more problems involved than advantages. Let us just say that certain political elements, as well as the criminal
made clear their dispicasure over the subject of the film, and it looked as if we might have problems.
They threatened you?
Well, there were warnings We shot the film in Saint-Etienne. where there is a young and dynamic local government that helped us a good deal. Anyway. what happened in Lyon is truc everywhere in France, 50 shooting the film in another town without nanting it makes
You know, when we shot the sequence in which Fayard is killed, we shot it at night. We were making noise, of course, in a residential neighhourhood.
Maybe it wasn't anything to do with the subject of the tum or with SAC or anytlog else Maybe people were just sick of us and wanted to sleep.
Nevertheless, bullets flew almost like in the scene we were
We threw ourselves the ground, bullets being bullets, no matter why someone was shooting.
sary organisation.
The result was bizarre. SAC took Boisset to court and got an injunction delete relerences to the organisation.
Boisser bleeped out the word SAC every time it came up, but audiences responded by shout ing "SAC" over each bleep!
SAC WYLL forried when General de Gaulle came to power to avert a military coup in 1958. IL was designed to combat the fascist terrorists of
OAS by their own methods"
BODYGUARD
But SAC continued after the end of the Alperian war and che demise of the OAS. Today it is
bodyguard for Gaullist leaders HAC - Jacques and, as le Sherif shows, a political mafia.
The film shows how SAC works in tandem with its old enemies of the OAS TEREOTESE and even murder, palitical and business oppor
Boisset Amrican film was a strong influence on him as for so many of his generation of French directors
That is evident in Le Sherif, which uses the fast moving form of the Hollywood theiler That form also presents an of the links between Gaullist politics and business himser a critical dies allis But Boisset does hero and the judicial system.
high-minded magistrate crumbles under pressure to use the violent methods of a Dirty Harry.
It's a neat reversal of the stereotype of the independent
who normally represents the defence of capitalist justice against its erosion by "biberal" values. This isn't the greates political film ever made, butit's worth a visit.
Le Sherif is showing at the Gala Royal, Marble Arch,
NFT '68 FROM 2 lo 12 July, the National Film Theatre in London is screening a season of French films on May-Jan '6R. A leaflet with details of the programme Is available trom the box office: 01-928 3232/3.
HALF
MOON
THEATRE
27 Alie St. London EJ, Tel: 01-480 6465.
ALFREDO GALVEZ
12 Shifts of Gear.
by Juan Vera.
A sensitive and human
play about changes in a
peasant village in Chile
during the Allende
regime
Until 22 July, at 8pm.
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE 29 Juno 1978 page 15
Page 16 scan of this page
RULES
Pubication of the "Yeilow Card' has been banned
An attempt by National Council of Capers to pupusa toe card in Lour i The Was Dr Gatee to
Rights was prevented by the Government in August 1977.
Publication, said the Government, was a breach of F
(Hranch),
as per details given.
A/C to be debited.
Branch, 19 Upper Street, London NI OPJ. Our sorting code number: 30,94.57.
First Payment Due.
Antiout:
HOW BRITISH
TROOPS IN
IRELAND BREAK
THEIR OWN
SOCIALIST CHALLENGE publishes here the 'Yellow Card' instructions given to every British soldier serving in the North of Ireland.
These instructions are meant goldiers are allowed to open fire.
Crown copynight But a report op the banning the in the Irish Times added that Civil the document was "restricted' under the Official Secrets Act, and that printing the prolubited under the D. Notice
Socialist Challenge publishes the Yellow Card in the aftermath of the killing by British troops of throe members of the
IRISH DEMONSTRATION End the Torture, End the Silence
Political Status for Political Prisoners
9 July, London. Assemble Marble Arch 2.30pm.
OUR FUND DRIVE
STANDING ORDER AUTHORITY • Name of your bank
Dear Sirs, Please make payment to the debit of the ascount specified
(Your Account number)
Payee: 0179678 (Our Account mumber) at Lloyds Bank, Islingtan
And continue until Furtber notice
, Frequency:
This order cancels all previous orders to the same payce and wil continue until written molice to the contrary is received by you.
- Your signarure.
Socialist Challenge
to govern when
IKA and a passerby in Belfast last week There is conclusive evidence that these killings broke the Yellow Card rules in at least
CArd: 15 thee ways. Bat poople in tus
country have been denied such
tion of the rules themselves are banned For the full story turn to page 10.
THE APPEAL In last week's sper for our supporters to di
MCLE 1018055(Address) [304.83 MIne In
highest weekly fund drive total since Socialist Chullenge launched, but today we need it more than ever.
(Your name) One supporter contributed
nearly
The writer
Seventh Man and Painter of Our Time, sent a contriaution to the paper. but mened: With my best wisher for the paper, which goes from strength to strength.
To help save the paper we
for regular bankers order do All our were written to last week requesting that they make such a
-Karl Marx
Exclusive
into their pockets met a A hankers order
In seven day That 1s the Socialist Challenge. was APOLOGIES
a third of the week's
Glasgow offices open. also com SULLEN
Aware Challenge every
G Name
Address
Hering balone Thing
Anon ciebt new monthly donations. J. Fletcher
form is printed here. All you have to do a fill it in and return it to D. Vulliamy J. Berger
Our apologies to our Scortist supporters. In last week's D. Russell paper we rapped their knuckles : Henrick
for failing to contribute to the fund drive. However last June M.B. it was agrood they would use M. Chanan money they raised to keep the
Socialist Challenge P. Purton M. Shinn
This week our thanks to: C. Stoneman
Summer sub - £2
Want to be sure of Socialist Chullenge for the summer!
There are two easy wars to be
of receiving Socialis week during the sentiner/ Atthat time it way this page.
Domestic: 6 months, £5. 12 months, €10 Abroad: Per annum -- Airmail, £16.50. Surface, £10 Domestie special offer: July-September, £2
Tesciose a donation for the Fighting Fund of
Complete and return to:
Socialist Challenge, 328/9 Upper Street, London NI.
ast Ltd. for Socisilet Challenge, 32819 Upper St., London N.1. Printed by Goodhead Press Ltd., 25 Murdock Road, Bicester.
his action is
You mey time after due moming.
5.00
Hudderstield readers 20.00
1.00 21.00
World Cup lottery
Camden supporters 8.03
2.00 100.00
5.00 LeicesTer Stam pr 15,00
10.00 5.00
be difficult lo obtain the paper regularly because our sellers or you may be on holidas.
Fiestly, take out a specia cheap sutscription. E2 for 3 months — ful in the form on Cheques, POs and Money Orders should be made payable to "Socialist Challenge'.
Hull readers 2.60 S. Encinob R. Ansan 28.00 TOTAL 5304.83
INFLATION
With this the overall tota has now reached E1915.14 and anocher slab of wall has been removed to tevcal the mystery quole. In the previous quarters OHE LOST MESDECE LINE NE has been well beaten, but to survive with inflation today we have had to raise the target lo €2500
In the last few days of Jutte we nerd near t thik
Secondiv, pluce an order with your local bramch of W. H. Smith, through a procedure called *Customers Special Order This operative through most branches of Smiths. However, as they have no hranches in Scotland it only applies to our English and Welsh readers.
← Socialist Challenge No. 51, 22 June 1978Socialist Challenge No. 53, 6 July 1978 →